+18 | Commercial Content | T&C's Apply | Play Responsibly | Publishing Principles
This page contains affiliate links. When you purchase through the links provided, we may earn a commission.
Weston McKennie USMNT United States Mexico 2023Getty

How can the USMNT cope without Weston McKennie or Sergino Dest? The best U.S. starting XI for Nations League final vs Canada

The U.S. men's national team heads into the Nations League final riding high after their best performance against their fiercest rival in quite some time. To put it lightly, the U.S. took Mexico apart, dominating them all over the field in a straightforward, yet still overly chaotic, win.

In an ideal world, the U.S. would simply run it back in Sunday's final against Canada, deploying the same team to keep the momentum moving. This isn't an ideal world, though, due to that aforementioned chaos.

Weston McKennie and Sergino Dest will both miss the finale after earning straight red cards in the win over Mexico. Neither dismissal has been overly criticized, as both were sent off for matching the passion of the game, but the fact is that the U.S. is now somewhat shorthanded for a big game against a solid Canada team.

Because of that, B.J. Callaghan has some massive decisions to make in his second game in charge. How does he replace two key players, both of whom were spectacular against El Tri? Does he make any other changes in the XI, potentially at striker or centerback? And how does he balance a midfield that is now without both McKennie and Tyler Adams?

GOAL takes a look at what lineup Callaghan should go with for Sunday night's final!

This page contains affiliate links. When you subscribe through the links provided, we may earn a commission.

Sign up here for MLS Season Pass through Apple TV and watch every MLS match, including the playoffs!

  • Matt Turner World Cup 2022Getty

    GK: Matt Turner

    No wasting time here; Turner is starting.

    He was rarely tested against Mexico, as the USMNT bossed the game, but one would expect Canada to provide a bit more pressure due to their elite-level attackers.

  • Advertisement
  • ONLY GERMANY Antonee Robinson USAImago Images

    LB: Antonee Robinson

    After another solid performance against Mexico, Robinson will almost certainly remain in the XI.

    Any slight chance that he'd be benched went out the window when Dest was sent off, as the USMNT's lack of depth at fullback means he'll be in the XI again.

  • Miles Robinson USMNT 2022Getty Images

    CB: Miles Robinson

    Thursday night's win was exactly the type of performance that showed why, given all he's been through, many remain so convinced by Robinson.

    He's all the way back from his horrible Achilles injury, as evidenced by his fantastic effort against Mexico. The Atlanta United star had an answer for everything Mexico threw at him, which is why he should remain in the XI.

  • Chris Richards 2022-23Getty

    CB: Chris Richards

    Why ruin a good thing?

    This centerback spot is one that will be up for grabs, with it likely coming down to Richards or Walker Zimmerman. The latter, of course, has the experience edge and will also be well-rested, having only come on for a cameo against Mexico.

    But the Richards-Robinson partnership worked really, really well against El Tri, who never really bothered that duo. It's a tough call, for sure, but it seems like a good idea to keep that pairing together as a reward for their solid performance.

  • Scally Pulisic USMNT 2023Getty

    RB: Joe Scally

    We know this is one change the U.S. will make, with Scally the obvious replacement for the suspended Dest.

    Oddly enough, the USMNT could be better for it, even with how good Dest was against Mexico. There's a good chance that the right-back will be forced to go toe-to-toe with Alphonso Davies, something Scally has done a few times in the Bundesliga. The Borussia Monchengladbach defender has notoriously performed well against Bayern Munich, so he won't be overawed by anything Davies brings.

    Because of that, the U.S. should be just fine even with Dest out.

  • De la Torre USMNT 2022Getty

    CM: Luca de la Torre

    The second enforced change for the USMNT, as McKennie is suspended as well.

    That one is a tougher pill to swallow. The U.S. are quite obviously a better team with McKennie on the field and his absence in the center of the field will hurt in a big way, especially with Tyler Adams also out.

    Luca de la Torre or Johnny Cardoso are the two options to replace him. The former is much smoother on the ball and could cause Canada's midfield trouble. The latter is more defensively sound, a true No.6.

    We'll go with De la Torre, an option that comes with both risk and reward. If the U.S. can possess the ball and not turn it over in dangerous areas, they should be able to survive.

  • MusahGetty Images

    CM: Yunus Musah

    Playing in a double-pivot alongside McKennie, Musah had a pretty solid game against Mexico.

    Without Adams behind him, the Valencia midfielder had to hold back on some of his more attacking instincts, instead putting in a really strong defensive performance in a game that really called for it. He combined well with McKennie and Gio Reyna and, quite frankly, dominated the midfield, even if he was overshadowed a bit by the other two.

    He'll stay in the XI, no doubt.

  • Gio Reyna USMNT United States Mexico 2023Getty

    CAM: Gio Reyna

    He didn't get on the scoresheet, but Reyna's performance against Mexico was his best in quite some time.

    Playing in a central role, Reyna looked significantly more comfortable than he did in the same position during the March window. He was confident, direct and influential, showing why that may just be his role going forward.

  • Christian Pulisic USMNT 2022 World CupGetty

    LW: Christian Pulisic

    Christian Pulisic is obviously starting.

    He was the clear Man of the Match against El Tri, scoring twice while running circles around Mexico's defense. It was another typical USMNT performance from the winger, who continued to step up in big games.

    He'll play in another on Sunday as he looks to lead the U.S. to another trophy.

  • Folarin Balogun USMNT United States Mexico 2023Getty

    ST: Folarin Balogun

    A tough call here for Callaghan, but Balogun should get the nod.

    Ricardo Pepi was good off the bench, scoring almost immediately to effectively end the game. The ex-FC Dallas star is deserving of minutes going forward, for sure.

    But this is Balogun's moment. He didn't score against Mexico and didn't really create many chances of his own, but he did show how much pull he has in the middle of the field. It's a bit of a copout to say after a goalless game, but Balogun does have a presence that impacted the match, even if it was indirectly.

    He'll be hunting for that first goal, though, and the USMNT will hope it comes in this finale.

  • Tim Weah USMNT World Cup 2022Getty

    RW: Tim Weah

    If you want a clear example of why Weah starts, look at the USMNT's second goal.

    He has an ability to drive the ball to the endline and make defenses uncomfortable. It's a key tenant of the USMNT's style of play: let Weah run into space and find whoever's open in the box.

    The connection he has with his teammates is fantastic, making him a key piece of everything the U.S. does in the attack.