Reo-Coker said on CBS Sports Golazo: "It's good to see him enjoying his football but I want Pulisic to have that edge about him, he needs to take that next level and embrace the pressure, and the limelight. I still don't think he is doing it. I don't think he's gone there to say, 'This Milan team is me, I am one of the key players for Milan'. I think he is having a great season but I wouldn't say he is the man for AC Milan. That is what he needs to do because that is what he has to compete against for the top of the young players we talk about in world football."
While pundit Nico Cantor was more positive about Pulisic's season, he felt comparisons with Bellingham, who had a bigger impact at Dortmund than the American from a young age, were unfair.
"But we are not comparing Pulisic to one of the best players in the world right now. Jude Bellingham is just a whole different category of player. This is Pulisic, not a potential next Ballon d'Or winner, you can't expect him to do Jude Bellingham things if he is not Jude Bellingham," he said.