The Everton defender initially won the ball with his sliding challenge but followed through dangerously, catching the Argentine midfielder high on the leg. Referee Sam Barrott issued a yellow card, and after a VAR review, the decision stood, as officials determined the challenge was "reckless" but not a clear and obvious error.
Following a review of the incident, Professional Game Match Officials Limited (PGMOL) has acknowledged that Tarkowski should have been sent off. The organization determined that the challenge met the criteria for serious foul play, which should have resulted in a VAR intervention to upgrade the yellow card to a red.