Alves has changed his story a number of times since first being taken into custody. He originally claimed to not know his alleged victim, but then admitted to meeting her in the bathroom of the club in question – although he maintained that nothing had happened. When biological evidence was presented, the ex-Juventus and Paris Saint-Germain defender claimed to have had consensual oral sex performed on him. In April 2023, after more test results, Alves admitted for the first time that he did have sex with the women in question – again saying it was consensual and that he had tried to hide his infidelity from his wife.