Farewell Andre Onana - the worst Man Utd signing of the past 20 years

Onana has made countless mistakes across his 102 appearances in a United shirt, with not all of them being punished. If they had, it's entirely possible that Amorim's side would have been in a genuine fight to avoid relegation last season. Officially, just 22 of his errors have led to goals being conceded, but that is still an insanely high number considering he's only been at Old Trafford for two years.

Many of those have come in extremely important matches, too. Indeed, Onana was almost single-handedly responsible for United's group stage exit from the Champions League in 2023-24, shipping 15 goals as the team finished bottom of a group containing Bayern Munich, Copenhagen and Galatasaray. He somehow let a tame Leroy Sane shot slip under him in a 4-3 defeat to Bayern Munich on matchday one, before passing the ball straight to Dries Mertens when United were locked at 2-2 with Galatasaray in their second game at Old Trafford, which forced Casemiro into a red card tackle on the Belgian.

United ended up losing 3-2 that day, and could only manage a 3-3 draw in the return fixture in Turkey, which effectively sealed their early elimination. Onana was beaten by two Hakim Ziyech free-kicks, the second of which he pushed into the net from a central position despite being under no pressure. "I’m not sure what he’s actually trying to do, punch it away with his right hand? It’s weak," United legend Paul Scholes told TNT Sports after the game. "He makes people nervous, he makes the defence nervous, he makes the whole team nervous. He makes simple saves look really, really difficult."

As Scholes observed, Onana has never shown any kind of authority in the United net. During his second Premier League home game for United against Nottingham Forest, he famously stayed rooted to his six-yard box when Taiwo Awoniyi ran through, and then bizarrely collapsed to the ground so that the striker could roll the ball into the net.

Onana showed similar levels of fear when allowing Jarrod Bowen to knock the ball in off his leg in United's 2-0 defeat away at West Ham on December 23, 2023, and three days later, he neglected to go and claim a teasing touchline free-kick from Aston Villa midfielder John McGinn, and the ball crept past him at the far post. It was clear early on that Onana couldn't command his box or save simple shots, but then-United coach Erik ten Hag stuck by the Cameroonian, having previously worked with him at Ajax, and defended his "strong character" when facing up to the media.

The Red Devils fell to eighth in the Premier League table by the end of the 2023-24 campaign, but Ten Hag was given a new contract on the back of an unlikely run to FA Cup glory. That success was in no way down to Onana, who was largely poor in United's hugely unconvincing semi-final win over Coventry and gifted Manchester City a way back into the game late on in the final by fumbling a low Jeremy Doku strike in at his near post.

United should have made signing a new goalkeeper a priority that summer, but instead, Ten Hag blew the best part of £100 million ($135m) on the likes of Matthijs de Ligt, Manuel Ugarte and Joshua Zirkzee, all of whom have struggled for consistency at Old Trafford. The Dutch coach was way out of his depth, and his misplaced faith in Onana led to his inevitable sacking just three months into the new season.

United only won three of their first nine Premier League games in 2024-25, and drew their opening three Europa League fixtures against FC Twente, Porto and Fenerbahce. Onana didn't add to his reel of shame during that run, but he was still constantly guilty of woeful positioning and a distinct lack of courage with aerial balls, and his uncertainty continued to filter through to the rest of the backline.

Ten Hag was ousted after a 2-1 loss at West Ham on October 27, which left United down in 14th in the Premier League. United part-owners INEOS moved quickly to lure Amorim away from Sporting CP as Ten Hag's successor, but the Portuguese inherited the mother of all messes, and quickly learned that all of his best laid plans would count for little with Onana serving as the last line of defence.

Amorim started with a 1-1 draw against Ipswich, a 4-0 win over Everton, and a 2-0 defeat to Arsenal, before United played host to surprise top-four contenders Nottingham Forest. Onana was at fault for two goals as Forest picked up their first victory at Old Trafford in 30 years, first letting a Morgan Gibbs-White pea roller in before being caught at sea by a looping Chris Wood header.

United then suffered a major Europa League scare when they fell behind away to Viktoria Plzen, as Onana was punished for a terrible pass out from the back once again. Of all Onana's weaknesses, his woeful distribution has been the most disappointing, because he was initially hailed as the finest ball-playing 'keeper on the continent after his initial arrival from Inter in 2023.

Amorim's men battled back to win that contest 2-1 and reach the knockout phase, but United lost three of their next four league outings, and Onana continued to be a complete liability. He even conceded directly from a Matheus Cunha corner in a 2-0 reversal at Wolves, which Premier League legend Chris Sutton described as "Under-12s stuff" in his BBC Sport column.

Onana would grab more unwanted headlines after the turn of the year as United struggled to build any kind of momentum under Amorim. He even managed to ruin the rare moments of encouragement, including when the Red Devils fought to a 3-2 win against Ipswich at Old Trafford after playing the entire second half with 10 men. 

Jaden Philogene opened the scoring for the visitors because of a communication mix-up between Onana and Patrick Dorgu, and doubled his account with a cross that went all the way in because the United 'keeper kept to his usual scared statue routine. But the worst was still yet to come.

Ahead of a Europa League quarter-final clash with Lyon, Onana had the audacity to claim that United were "way better" than the French team, prompting a scathing response from Nemanja Matic. "If you are one of the worst goalkeepers in Manchester United's history, you need to take care what you're talking about," said the Lyon midfielder, who played for the Red Devils between 2017 and 2022.

Onana fired back with an ill-advised dig at Matic's trophyless spell at Old Trafford, only to then prove the Serbian right with a shocking performance in the first leg of the tie at the Groupama Stadium. The former Ajax stopper was hopelessly deceived by a Thiago Almada free-kick in the first half, and with United holding a 2-1 lead in the final minute of second-half injury time, he fumbled a Corentin Tolisso shot straight into the path of Rayan Cherki, who was then able to dink in a dramatic equaliser from close range.

The Red Devils won a crazy second leg 5-4 after extra time and saw off Athletic Club in the next round to set up an all-English final against Tottenham, but Onana did not complete his redemption arc. He was far too static for Brennan Johnson's decisive goal in Bilbao, which saw Tottenham clinch their first trophy in 17 years and compound the worst season in United's entire history.

According to The Athletic, Onana requested a contract extension when he reported for United's first day of pre-season training in the summer, which "did not go down well with Amorim". The 29-year-old believed he was entitled to fresh terms after being stung with a standard 25 per cent wage cut that hit all of the players in the squad as a consequence of missing out on Champions League qualification, but didn't factor in his gross incompetence as one of the main reasons for the team's failure.

Onana went on to suffer a hamstring injury that ruled him out of United's tour of the United States, though it was reported that he would be fit for the club's 2025-26 curtain raiser against Arsenal. Amorim's eventual decision to opt for Bayindir caused quite a stir, and the Turkish 'keeper retained his place for United's second Premier League game against Fulham, despite being to blame for Arsenal's winning goal at Old Trafford.

“I try to see the game, I try to imagine the next game, I try to put the best players to win the game. So I did that," Amorim said to Sky Sports before the 1-1 draw at Craven Cottage. That brutally honest admission fuelled speculation over Onana's future, but he was given a final chance to silence his critics and save his United career in a subsequent Carabao Cup second-round tie against Grimsby.

To say he blew it would be the understatement of the century. Charles Vernam put the League Two side in front in the 22nd minute when he fired past Onana at his near post, and moments later, Tyrell Warren tapped in the home side's second after Onana flapped at a cross with his eyes closed. United came back to force penalties, but Grimsby won the shootout, with Onana only managing to save one spot-kick out of 12.

United only invested £48m ($64m) in Onana's 'talent', a relatively modest fee compared to the eye-watering amount they paid for similarly disappointing signings like Rasmus Hojlund, Antony, Jadon Sancho, Paul Pogba and Romelu Lukaku. But all of those players, to varying degrees, at least showed some positive signs, whether in short bursts of form or by simply busting a gut for the collective cause.

Onana has no redeeming qualities to speak of. Some argue he has been a victim of United's structural issues, with no protection in place that allows him to play his usual game. But that excuse doesn't fly when looking back over the basic nature of his many gaffes. 

He has not even reached the bare minimum standard required to be a Premier League goalkeeper, let alone for the biggest club in English football. And worst of all, Onana doesn't even look like he cares, as Paul Parker pointed out earlier this year.

"He’s just not good enough, and I don’t think he even looks like a goalkeeper at all," the former United defender told SpilXperten. "Another thing I really don’t like about Onana is his mentality. It doesn’t seem to bother him when Manchester United concedes a goal. You never see him standing there shouting or scolding his defence, like [David] de Gea or Peter Schmeichel always did. For them, keeping a clean sheet was a matter of life and death. It meant everything to them."

At Trabzonspor, Onana can pocket a tidy sum while putting in minimal effort. He will be "alright" in a less pressurised environment. The harsh truth is, he never had the inner strength and humility to succeed at Old Trafford, and United will be far better off without him.