Even though Cleveland carried six quarterbacks on the roster this summer, there was never a true battle for the starting role — Joe Flacco held the inside track from day one.
A hamstring issue sidelined Kenny Pickett, effectively ending any real veteran head-to-head. Rookie Shedeur Sanders generated some early buzz in the preseason opener but an oblique setback quickly cooled the hype. Fellow rookie Dillon Gabriel also missed time with a hamstring problem, while Tyler Huntley was brought in simply to eat up practice snaps. Meanwhile, link-placeholder-4 remained stuck on the PUP list.
Through it all, Flacco remained the steady presence and obvious No. 1. He didn’t take the field in preseason action until the finale, but his grip on the job was never in doubt.
The logic behind the choice is clear: Flacco thrived in Kevin Stefanski’s system last season, guiding the Browns into the playoffs. At 40, his arm strength still gives the offense the vertical threat it needs, and his experience ensures he can manage a run-first scheme while keeping the offense in rhythm.
The real test, however, lies in ball security. Flacco tossed eight interceptions across five games in 2023 and seven in six starts with Indianapolis the year before. If he can rein in the turnovers, Cleveland’s Myles Garrett-anchored defense should keep them in every contest — giving the Browns a fighting chance week after week.