Presented byModeloDrink responsibly. Modelo Especial® Beer. Imported by Crown Imports, Chicago, IL For 21+
Zidane options HIC Getty Images

Man Utd, Bayern Munich or Chelsea - who needs serial-winner Zinedine Zidane in the dugout most? Ranking Frenchman's options as former Real Madrid boss eyes a return to management

A movie premiere is not the most likely place for the starting pistol to be fired on an almighty managerial tug of war. But at the recent maiden screening of a documentary charting the career of former Italy and Juventus boss Marcello Lippi, Zinedine Zidane's seven words to a reporter did exactly that.

"I'd certainly like to return to the bench," the legendary Frenchman said - and it appears that several top clubs across the continent were listening. That Zidane was speaking within the context of that prospective job coming in Italy didn't matter. In the hours and days that followed his comment, news feeds were flooded with stories linking Zidane with a string of the continent's best-known sides.

This is not the first time his name has been mentioned for the biggest jobs, of course. Since leaving his beloved Real Madrid for a second time in 2021, Zidane has had the pick of a whole host of different roles. However, up to now, he has proved to be an extremely discerning customer, turning down some truly massive opportunities after the projects failed to enthuse him.

  • Berhalter-USMNTGetty

    Biding his time

    For instance, Zidane has reportedly been considered by Manchester United twice previously, once back in 2019 when Jose Mourinho's time was coming to an end, and then more recently in 2021 before Ralf Rangnick was chosen as Ole Gunnar Solskjaer's interim replacement.

    Juventus were also sniffing around when Andrea Pirlo departed, eventually opting to rehire Max Allegri, who has endured a topsy-turvy time in Turin ever since. Paris Saint-Germain have been among his other suitors, with links most prominent when it became evident that Christophe Galtier would be sacked towards the end of last season. Again though, Zidane kept his distance and Luis Enrique instead landed French football's top job.

    It's not just been club roles either. The USMNT are understood to have sounded out the 51 year old when Gregg Berhalter spent a period under investigation. Zidane showed little willing to head Stateside, however, even with the promise of leading the Stars and Stripes at a home World Cup in 2026.

  • Advertisement
  • Didier Deschamps France 2023Getty Images

    The France dream is dead - for now

    In fact, despite all of the rumours, there's only been one job that Zidane has ever felt close to taking since his Madrid exit. When France lost in the 2022 World Cup final, it was unclear whether Didier Deschamps would stay on as Les Bleus boss. This led to Zidane's name being floated for the job, amid criticism of Deschamps' perceived negative team selection.

    Then, with the dust still settling on France's dramatic defeat in Qatar, it was confirmed that the manager had extended his deal until 2026. This was obviously disappointing from Zidane's perspective, but the issue soon snowballed into a full-on national crisis thanks to then-French Football Federation president Noel Le Graet.

    Speaking to RMC Sport at the time, the 82 year old said: "Did Zidane tried to reach me? Certainly not, I wouldn't even have picked up the phone anyway." He added: "I've never met him, we never considered parting with Didier."

    His dismissive comments attracted widespread outroar, with Kylian Mbappe telling him not to "disrespect the legend like that", while French sports minister Amelie Oudea-Castera also chimed in. Le Graet attempted to wriggle off the hook with an apology, but it was no use. A few months earlier, his position had been weakened by an expose in a French outlet So Foot, which included accusations of sexual harassment and inappropriate workplace behaviour at FFF, and the president would tender his resignation in February 2023.

    Criticism of Zidane was the straw that broke the camel's back, which is telling for just how highly the 1998 World Cup hero is regarded in France. However, with Deschamps still in charge, his dream of managing his national team anytime soon is dead. The situation may change if Les Bleus implode at the Euros this summer, but Zidane's recent comments suggest he is tired of waiting and would be amenable to re-entering the club game if the right opportunity emerged.

  • Zinedine Zidane 2016-17Getty Images

    The perfect man for Real Madrid

    And it's little surprise that so many top sides would be willing to offer him that route back to the dugout. That Zidane remains so highly regarded after an unusually long break is testament of the quite incredible job he did during his first spell at the Santiago Bernabeu. Airlifted in from the club's second team to pick up the wreckage left by Rafa Benitez's ill-fated spell in charge, just a few months later he had led Los Blancos to the Champions League final, where they edged out bitter rivals Atletico Madrid at San Siro.

    And the trophies just kept on coming thereafter. The following campaign, Madrid won La Liga, the Club World Cup and the Champions League, with Zidane adding a ridiculous, third-straight European Cup to his collection during the 2017-18 campaign. He left shortly after, insisting the club needed a "change" to push on, but he wasn't away for long.

    Following failed stints from Julen Lopetegui and Santiago Solari, Madrid put up the Zidane beacon again in March 2019. This time he was tasked with essentially rebuilding the team following Cristiano Ronaldo's departure and La Liga glory was savoured in his first full season in charge. That title tilt was built on a measly defence and the goals of Karim Benzema, but the 2020-21 campaign was less magical, as Los Blancos failed to lift a single piece of silverware.

    Despite still being under contract until 2022, Zidane left at the end of that season, somewhat acrimoniously. An open letter to fans read: "Right now, things are different… I’m leaving because I feel the club no longer has the faith in me I need, nor the support to build something in the medium or long term."

  • 20240221_Thomas_Tuchel(C)Getty images

    Bayern Munich are interested

    Zidane wasn't the first coach to be ground down by life under the ever-demanding Florentino Perez, but if he is truly refreshed and ready to go again, he will have no shortage of offers this summer. One club understood to be interested is Bayern Munich, following the news that Thomas Tuchel will be departing at the end of the season.

    News of the ex-Chelsea boss' exit wasn't surprising. Die Roten currently trail Xabi Alonso's exceptional Bayer Leverkusen by eight points in the Bundesliga title race while their Champions League prospects hang by a thread following a disappointing last-16 first-leg defeat to Lazio.

    In typically Bayern fashion - who have made a habit of hoovering up talent from their German rivals - Alonso is thought to be their No.1 choice. But with Liverpool pushing hard to snap up the Spaniard too, Zidane has emerged as another option.

    His hire would make a good deal of sense. Bayern's dressing room dynamics are a mess right now, with pro and anti Tuchel factions apparently emerging. This echos a wider pattern of intersquad discord over the past few seasons, with Leroy Sane and Sadio Mane even coming to blows after a Champions League game last season, raising concerns that the infamous FC Hollywood days are returning to Bavaria.

    Zidane showed during his time at Madrid that one of his key assets is handling egos. Cristiano Ronaldo, Karim Benzema and countess other big-name players only have good things to say about the Frenchman, and when they were at the peak of their powers his side's exuded an aura.

    It was this mentality - created by Zidane - that carried them to the majority of their success. He's not a 'philosophy coach' like Pep Guardiola or Roberto De Zerbi. He's tactically flexible, with his greatest strength instead being ensuring the psychological dynamics of the team are elite.

    After experiencing issues with two such blue-sky thinking managers - Tuchel and Julian Nagelsmann - in the recent past, turning to Zidane would seem to make sense for Bayern.

  • 20240225 Mauricio Pochettino(C)Getty Images

    Chelsea likely a non-starter

    There also seems to be Premier League options for Zidane too, though. Chelsea, for example. His name was mentioned last season after Graham Potter's short-lived reign came to an abrupt end, but the Blues instead opted for what looks like being an ill-fated Frank Lampard into Mauricio Pochettino combo.

    The latter was handed a significant blow to his long-term job security by Jurgen Klopp's young Liverpool side in the Carabao Cup final recently, with that defeat doing little to answer questions about whether the Argentine is the right man to squeeze something coherent out of the club's smorgasbord of a squad.

    And therein lies the issue with Chelsea's potential pursuit of Zidane. Although he has previous with integrating young players into the first team, with Federico Valverde, Vinicius Junior and, to a lesser extent, Rodrygo all coming into the senior side during his time in Madrid, it's a whole different kettle of fish in west London.

    Chelsea are still spending like an elite club, but they are currently a million miles away from breaking back into the elite group of Premier League sides. In many ways, predicting how good a job Zidane might do at Stamford Bridge is a wasted exercise. His recent pickiness tells us he simply won't even consider an approach by Todd Boehly and Co.

  • Ten-Hag-Ratcliffe-Man-UtdGetty/GOAL

    Ratcliffe's dream appointment

    That's not to say that Zidane's prospects of managing in the Premier League are zero. Once again, there's rumblings at Old Trafford that the Frenchman could be on the club's radar. It's not a certainty that Erik ten Hag will be given his marching orders in the summer, but after poor showings in the Champions League and Carabao Cup, his job would be in serious jeopardy if the Red Devils do not finish in the top four this season.

    Sir Jim Ratcliffe's part-takeover adds some spice to the situation too. It was reported recently that the Francophile's "dream" appointment would be Zidane, provided Ten Hag is sacked.

    Culturally, it seems like a good fit. The media scrutiny that comes with being United boss is legendary - Ten Hag was even papped for having the audacity to go to lunch with his wife too soon after his side's Premier League defeat to Fulham. Zidane likely would not be fazed by this pressure cooker, however, with Madrid being one of the only club's on the planet who command as much attention - positive and negative - as the Red Devils.

    His exceptional trophy record is likely getting Ratcliffe excited too. The billionaire is enjoying somewhat of a honeymoon period currently, earning plaudits for his no-nonsense hiring and firing, but a trophy in his first full season will be vital if he is to retain the support of the club's feverishly passionate fanbase.

    Zidane's aforementioned dressing-room handling skills would be useful at Old Trafford as well. Hire the Frenchman and United would likely see a marked decrease in the amount of leaked stories finding their way into the press from disgruntled players, agents and staff.

  • Language barrier

    Overall then, Zidane appears to be best suited to joining a team that plays in red this summer, though there will be issues to iron out before either prospective move is completed. As well as all the normal financial consideration, Zidane's previous comments regarding language will be of concern to both clubs.

    “Certain conditions make things more difficult,” he told L'Equipe in 2022, when quizzed on where he will coach next. “Language, for example. When people say to me, ‘Do you want to go to Manchester?’ Well, I understand English but I don’t fully master it. I know there are coaches who go to clubs without speaking the language, but I work differently. To win, many elements come into play. It’s a global context. I know what I need to win.”

    Therefore, Zidane would need convincing that this particular issue won't be a barrier for progress at whatever club decides to enter into negotiations.

  • Zidane UCLGettyImage

    Manchester or Bavaria?

    But which club should be pushing harder to hire the serial winner? While Bayern would benefit from his soft touch behind the scenes, the fact that they look set to complete a significant rebuild this summer - due to contract uncertainty surrounding several long-serving stars - might suggest that they require a more holistic-thinking hire.

    They require someone who can offer an all-encompassing philosophy for the club to follow, as Guardiola was tasked with back in 2013 and as Nagelsmann had hoped to do too. Zidane likely wouldn't be the best option out there for that particular task.

    United, meanwhile, seem more in need of a coach who can come and collect some trophies and re-establish them in the Champions League from the off. The wider restructuring that is required will fall more on the shoulders of their other likely hires: Dan Ashworth and Jason Wilcox.

    Having someone, like Zidane, who commands instant respect both in the dressing room and in the media, to complement this wider process appears an exciting prospect. No wonder Ratcliffe is seemingly so taken by the idea.