+18 or +21, depending on state | Commercial Content | T&C's Apply | Play Responsibly | Publishing Principles
This page contains affiliate links. When you purchase through the links provided, we may earn a commission.
Athletic Bilbao v Manchester United - UEFA Europa League 2024/25 Semi Final First LegGetty Images Sport

'The worst decision I've ever seen!' - VAR completely misses obvious Alejandro Garnacho handball seconds before Man Utd awarded controversial Europa League penalty that led to red card as fans fume & make 'corruption' claims

Article continues below

Article continues below

Article continues below

  • Man Utd beat Bilbao 3-0 in Europa League semi first leg
  • VAR didn't give a potential handball against Garnacho
  • Fans claim decision could've been a turning point
Follow GOAL on WhatsApp! 🟢📱
  • WHAT HAPPENED?

    Football fans were left fuming on Thursday night after VAR failed to spot what appeared to be a blatant handball by Garnacho in the build-up to Manchester United's controversial penalty during their Europa League semi-final first leg against Athletic Club. Bruno Fernandes converted the spot-kick to make it 2-0, and their opponents were reduced to 10 men with Dani Vivian being shown a red card, sparking a storm of outrage online as supporters slammed the officials and accused the system of "corruption" in one of the most hotly debated VAR calls of the season.

  • Advertisement
  • WHAT THE FANS ARE SAYING

    Manchester City fan @DxBruyneSZN wrote on X: "Athletic Club have been robbed. It’s a shambles really"

    User @FlorianFocus added: "I'm sorry but why is that a red card?"

    User @valverdismo888 tore apart the referees, writing: "Probably the worst decision i've ever seen and that's not an exaggeration. Handball on Garnacho, never a penalty and the ridiculous red card to top it off. Disgusting ref."

    @blaSkalda claimed that the referee should never be allowed to officiate another game in Europe: "Espen Eskas should be nowhere near European football. That's absolutely unbelievable stuff from him, he blocked Athletic players twice and intercept their pass twice... not even talking about the Garnacho handball before the goal, disgusting."

  • WHAT INAKI WILLIAMS SAID

    Following the game, Bilbao striker Inaki Williams was criticial of referee Eskas. "There are some plays that raise doubts," Williams told reporters (h/t United In Focus). "The play before the penalty comes from a handball by Garnacho, which the referee doesn’t see.

    “It’s a struggle between Vivian and him. All the slightest contact, he goes down, and it’s unfortunate that he called it.”

  • FBL-EUR-C3-ATHLETIC BILBAO-MANCHESTER UNITEDAFP

    THE BIGGER PICTURE

    United and Bilbao were going toe-to-toe in the opening 25 minutes of the game, until Casemiro's header broke the deadlock at San Mames. After that, captain Fernandes struck twice in eight minutes before half-time. Garnacho's potential handball not being given, and Vivian subsequently being sent off, allowed Ruben Amorim's men to take control, given them a healthy lead ahead of the second leg.

  • Bruno Fernandes Man Utd Nico Williams Athletic Bilbao(C)Getty Images

    WHAT NEXT?

    With the first leg finishing 3-0 and the second leg at Old Trafford, Amorim's men appear have one foot in the Europa League final, with the competition winners earning a spot in next season's Champions League. The second leg will be played next Thursday, May 8. Before that, the two teams will return to domestic affairs. Ernesto Valverde's side will take on Real Sociedad in the Basque derby on Sunday, while United will lock horns against Brentford on the same day.