Since signing for PSV ahead of the 2023-24 season, Pepi has mostly made appearances for the Eindhoven side off the bench. He finds himself behind veteran striker Luuk de Jong in the pecking order under manager Peter Bosz. However, that hasn't stopped Pepi from being a clinical striker for the Eredivisie table-toppers.
PSV have 33 points in 12 games to find themselves atop the Dutch top flight, with De Jong and Pepi both chipping in with six goals in 11 appearances. However, the latter has only played 418 minutes in the league. His overall numbers are even more astonishing; the 21-year-old is directly involved in a goal every 59 minutes since joining PSV.
Pepi has become a fixture for the USMNT, scoring 11 goals in 31 games already. Despite his effectiveness and incredible output, he hasn't been able to break into the PSV starting XI just yet and Netherlands international Hartman believes that Pepi is not rated as highly as he deserves.