Real Madrid ready to choose between Kylian Mbappe and Vinicius Jr as Xabi Alonso plots rebuild

Mbappe’s move to Madrid last summer, following the expiration of his PSG contract, was expected to elevate Los Blancos to greater heights. However, the opposite appears to have happened. While PSG has flourished since his departure, Real have stumbled, sparking concerns that the Frenchman’s presence has disrupted squad harmony, particularly with Vinicius. The duo often appeared disconnected on the pitch, while off it, tensions have allegedly been brewing. Sport suggests that both players have been criticised for their effort and attitude, with the Club World Cup semifinal serving as the latest example of their lackadaisical attitude while pressing.

After the defeat, Alonso echoed Carlo Ancelotti's frustrations with what he viewed as a lack of collective discipline and hunger, two traits that once defined Real’s identity. The Spaniard has inherited a fractured dressing room and a squad that seems to have lost its competitive edge. The data from this season paints a dire picture: 68 matches played, 15 defeats, and 84 goals conceded, matching the club’s worst-ever defensive record, set in 1998–99. Moreover, embarrassing defeats to Barcelona, PSG, Liverpool, and Arsenal have only highlighted the scale of the decline.

In response, club president Florentino Perez has given Alonso full authority to reshape the team and take decisive steps in evaluating and overhauling the squad. This includes one-on-one meetings with every player to assess their mindset and commitment. At the top of this list is Vinicius Jr.

The Brazilian’s conduct during the Club World Cup defeat has raised eyebrows. As Madrid trailed 3-0, Vinicius was seen laughing on the bench, a moment that reportedly infuriated the club’s hierarchy. While Real had been working on extending his contract beyond 2027, that process is now in doubt as the Brazilian has hit pause on renewal discussions. If there’s no significant change in his attitude, the club may consider parting ways.

In contrast, Mbappe appears to have stronger backing from Perez. Given the club’s seven-year pursuit of the Frenchman, it’s not surprising that the president remains firmly in his corner. And if Real are forced to choose between the two, the club would prefer to build around Mbappe.

Despite the friction, Alonso is expected to try and find a way to make the partnership work. Both Mbappe and Vinicius are among the most electrifying attacking talents in world football, and the ideal scenario would see them thrive together. However, finding the right tactical setup, one that balances their strengths while maintaining team structure, will be a massive challenge. The club legend has got a month to find the right combination before Real begin their La Liga campaign against Osasuna on August 19 at the Santiago Bernabeu.