The media just couldn't get enough of Balotelli. So many stories about him appeared in the tabloids, about him carrying £5,000 in cash when he got into a car crash, setting off fireworks in his own bathroom, visits to a women's prison - he was a goldmine for bizarre headlines.
There were the viral clips and images of his 'Why always me?' shirt after scoring against United, his losing battle to put on a bib for a warm-up, ripping off his shirt after scoring against Germany in Euro 2012. He was a constant source of comedy on and off the field, but for Mancini he was stressful.
"He's Mario. He's crazy – but I love him because he's a good guy," Mancini said, while six months later, he added: "There are different ways to help a guy like Mario. I don't speak with him every day, otherwise I would need a psychologist, but I speak with him because I don't want him to lose his quality. If Mario is not one of the best players in the world it will be his fault, because he has everything. Mario can be one of the top players in Europe. I don't want him to lose his talent."
Mancini's fears about 'Super Mario's' talent going to waste were shared by many football fans, and sadly, they would soon coming to fruition as, eventually, the forward crossed the line and the coach had had enough.
In April 2012, a studs up tackle on Alex Song in a 1-0 defeat to Arsenal earned Balotelli a three-game suspension - he was lucky to avoid an even longer ban. Mancini was furious. Balotelli later said: "He (Mancini) was angry. I remember on the bus, he said: ‘You’ll never play again!’”
Another time, it was a tackle on a team-mate that sparked outrage from Mancini, and things got physical. "In a training session, I said to players not to make stupid tackles on Gael [Clichy] because he was just coming back from injury. And then, Mario made a strong tackle on him. I was furious," Mancini told L'Equipe. "I grabbed him by the collar wanting to push him, but he is so strong physically I couldn't move him. From seeing the pictures, you would think that we came to blows, but nothing happened. He came into conflict with some team-mates because of his behaviour, and he wanted to return to Italy."
Still, Balotelli proved an important part of City's first Premier League title win, scoring 13 goals and even laid on the assist for Sergio Aguero in the dramatic 3-2 win against QPR that secured the title on that legendary final day of the 2011-12 season.
In January the following year, though, he was away back to Italy, joining AC Milan. "I’m happy he will become one of the best players in the world," Mancini said. "We love Mario and he deserves to have this chance. For me, no [he was not a problem]. Mario was like another one of my children. But you can be upset with him sometimes, but afterwards he’s a lovely lad. All the players [will miss him]. When he left the hotel, they were really sad. Mario is a good guy."