Cherundolo's debut season in Los Angeles was a record-breaking one, as he became the first manager to win both MLS Cup and the Supporters' Shield in his initial campaign. Since then, LAFC have struggled at times.
LAFC lost in the 2023 MLS Cup Final, and were eliminated in the 2024 Western Conference semifinals - despite having one of the highest payrolls in the league. The opening to this season has been underwhelming, with LAFC seventh in the West and bounced from the CONCACAF Champions League by Inter Miami in the quarterfinal stage.