Matt Turner remains a penalty shootout superstar - but USMNT goalkeeper's hopes of becoming a Premier League No.1 look over after Nottingham Forest blunders

'Nightmare' may be a bit too harsh, but it's close to being a fair way of painting this picture. Turner's move to Forest was supposed to give him a new stage to shine. It has instead wrecked his confidence thanks to a series of mistakes that seemingly couldn't stop snowballing.

Turner's shot-stopping ability has never been questioned. It has gotten him this far, after all. Despite a relatively late start as a goalkeeper, his ability to simply keep the ball out of the back of the net got him from Fairfield University to the New England Revolution and, ultimately, to Arsenal. Even that, however, has let him down in this first half-season as a Premier League starter.

Largely, Turner's errors have come when asked to play with the ball at his feet. Manchester United legend Gary Neville labeled the American as "useless" with the ball after a number of errors culminated in a Marcus Rashford goal in December.

Those errors seemingly sapped his confidence, as Turner hasn't even looked like his old self when it comes to saving the ball anymore. A recent finish by Gabriel Jesus in a loss to Turner's former club, Arsenal, earned Turner further criticism, as many believe the American could have done more to keep the ball out.

Turner, more than most, knows the loneliness of the goalkeeping position. His first real introduction to an American audience came due to a mistake, with a sequence during his college days landing him a spot on SportsCenter's Not Top 10. Since then, mistakes have largely been few and far between. That is, until this season.

Turner knows it, too. He's aware that things haven't gone well. And, in a recent interview with ESPN, he took ownership of it all.

"This is a results business," he said. "And we haven't been getting the results that we probably deserve or need."

"Everything that could possibly have gone wrong in certain moments has gone completely wrong," he added. "Sometimes as goalkeepers you might get away with one or two things, and it feels like this season I've gotten away with zero. It's tough to take."

Turner is tied for second in the Premier League in errors leading to goals with three. And, inevitably, those errors led Nottingham Forest, a notably unstable club, to try and shake things up in the January window.

Turner's status as No. 1 was always on shaky ground. Shortly after signing him from Arsenal this summer, Forest brought in another international goalkeeper, Greece's Odysseas Vlachodimos. For a time in the fall, Vlachodimos took over for Turner, who snatched the job back heading into the new year.

Forest, though, weren't done wheeling and dealing. Before the January transfer window closed, the club went out and signed Belgian shot-stopper Matz Sels from Strasbourg, seemingly in response to Turner's errors. In just a matter of months, the club went out and signed three legitimate first-team goalkeepers, proving that Forest had little faith in Turner despite their move for him in the summer.

Upon his arrival, Sels was immediately thrust into the XI, for a 1-1 draw with Bournemouth, a potentially key result in the relegation race. It's expected that he'll be back in goal this coming weekend against Newcastle, too.

But, in between, Turner was handed a chance at redemption in the FA Cup, and he certainly made the most of it.

With Sels ineligible for Wednesday's FA Cup fourth-round replay against Bristol City, Forest turned back to Turner. For some, it would have been difficult to rise to such an occasion. Just days after being told you weren't good enough, Turner was thrown back into the team, not on merit but because of a technicality.

Forest went up 1-0 early, with a goal from Divock Origi easing any nerves. Those nerves came rushing back just moments later, though. After a fantastic diving save from Turner on a long-range effort, Forest still conceded, with the team's inability to clear the ball leading to a looped finish from Jason Knight in the 14th minute.

Turner, despite his save, earned some criticism for that sequence. It was unfair, truthfully, with those on social media going at him largely basing that criticism on his past mistakes. There would be no criticizing him by the end, though, as he proved to be Forest's hero.

Long a penalty shootout expert, Turner flexed his skillset yet again on Wednesday. One big stop was all he needed, and it came in the second round of kicks when he pushed away a shot from Sam Bell. Forest's takers took care of business and onto the next round they went, thanks at least in part to Turner's big save.

“It has to give him confidence," said Forest boss Nuno Espirito Santo. "We know it is not easy for him after the decision we took to change in the Premier League, but his response is of a top professional. We are so happy. It was tough but it was worth it. The attitude and the character to never give up makes me very happy."

Despite his demotion, Turner doesn't seem eager to back down.

The American is very aware of the situation he is in. He's lost the confidence of the fanbase, for sure, who can regularly be seen criticizing him on social media. Wednesday's save may do a bit to help that, but Turner still has a long way to go to prove himself once again.

The question, though, is if he'll get the chance to. There's no guarantee we'll see much of him again in a Forest shirt, but Turner is backing himself to battle his way back.

"Now I've got a real fight on my hands for the position," Turner told ESPN. "I'm no stranger to being in these types of scenarios. I've been overlooked and doubted many times in my life and my career, and I wouldn't have gotten to this point if I wasn't confident in myself. I can be somebody that has a real impact on this football club."

Despite Turner's optimism, and you can't fault him for it, there's also a need to look at the reality of the situation. And that reality is that, with both the Nations League and Copa America looming, there's no guarantee that Turner will be getting many games to continue rediscovering that confidence that has eroded this season.

Turner, though, isn't quite in danger of losing the USMNT gig. Part of that is because there is real trust there. Having earned the job on the road to the 2022 World Cup, Turner has never been anything less than spectacular in a USMNT shirt. He's a good locker room presence, a good shot-stopper, a reliable No. 1. It doesn't seem likely, even with these setbacks, that his spot is in danger. It wasn't when he was on the bench at Arsenal; it almost certainly won't be now.

Part of the reason why, though, is that there is no clear contender for the gig. Ethan Horvath, who joined him on the World Cup roster, recently joined Coventry City after essentially sitting out the first half of the season as Forest's third choice. Gaga Slonina, the goalkeeper of the future, is still navigating his first season as a starter in Europe for Eupen, making a starting gig at a major tournament a massive, massive leap. MLS options like Zack Steffen, Drake Callendar or Patrick Schulte won't be in midseason form by the time the Nations League rolls around in March, although that could change come this summer's Copa America.

For now, Turner's USMNT job seems somewhat safe. Going forward, though, it seems he'll have some decisions to make.

The fact is that Turner is headed toward a crossroads. Goalkeepers, in particular, need to be playing. And, if that isn't going to happen at Nottingham Forest, and it doesn't seem like it will, Turner will need to look elsewhere to find it.

Will any team in the Premier League trust him again as a No. 1? Barring a significant change, probably not. Goalkeeping is an unforgiving position, and the English ecosystem is even more unforgiving than that. Once folks in England make up their mind about a player, it's hard to change it, particularly when you have a lowlight reel of mistakes like Turner does. Clubs can always splash cash on a replacement, and it didn't take long for Forest to do exactly that, did it?

So, now what? What next for Turner who, at 29, is very much entering his prime as a goalkeeper? Does he stick it out in England and fight for another chance? Can he find a good gig in another top league? Could an MLS club convince him to come back home and immediately become one of the best in the league once again?

Those questions will be answered in the summer, for sure. Turner's days as Nottingham Forest's No. 1 are over, at least for now, and the USMNT goalkeeper will have plenty of soulsearching to do as he prepares for this next phase of his career.