Cleverley took the reins at Vicarage Road last season and led the Hornets to a mid-table 14th-place finish in the Championship during his debut campaign. Despite that relatively stable showing, he was relieved of his duties as the club opted for a new direction heading into the 2025–26 season.
The Pilgrims had reportedly shortlisted four potential candidates for the job. Among the names considered was Jack Wilshere, another former England international who recently stepped in as interim head coach at Norwich City. The ex-Arsenal playmaker was interviewed as part of the selection process, but is no longer believed to be in contention, paving the way for Cleverley’s expected appointment.