The midfielder had a troubled start to the season as he had to spend a significant period on the sidelines after sustaining a leg injury on international duty with the USMNT earlier in 2023. Although he returned to action in September, he has failed to earn the trust of Dortmund manager, Edin Terzic, and has been limited to substitute appearances from the bench. Despite Reyna's struggles in Germany, Berhalter has called him up for USMNT's home and away CONCACAF Nations League quarterfinal against Trinidad and Tobago but the tactician did reveal that his minutes will be closely monitored.