Are you 24 or older?

Help us verify your age by providing an honest response. This site contains gambling advertising for 24+.

Age-restricted content

You’re not old enough to view betting content. You’ll be redirected to the homepage.

alt
+18 | Commercial Content | T&C's Apply | Play Responsibly | Publishing Principles
Chelsea FC v Manchester United - Premier League 2026/27Getty Images Sport
Translated by

From striker to accused: former Liverpool star says this player has become a burden on Manchester United

The tables turned quickly on Lisandro Martinez at Manchester United. Weeks ago he came out swinging, criticising the club's management and holding them responsible for failing to strengthen the squad, even hinting that the Red Devils could not keep pace with Europe's elite in the Champions League. Now the Argentine defender is the one in the firing line after his sending off against Chelsea.

Martinez left Manchester United a man down and helped condemn them to another defeat, a 2-0 loss that deepened their crisis.

Winless in their last nine matches across all competitions, United have slipped to 17th. Their tally has stalled on 7 points, with just a single Premier League win since the season began.

  • From criticising the management to the worst performance

    Martinez had opened fire on Manchester United's officials following the 2-0 defeat to Atletico Madrid in the Champions League, criticising the weak activity in the transfer market and demanding that the management, led by sporting director Jason Wilcox, provide additional players capable of competing.

    The Argentine defender said at the time that he had expected greater support from the management after last season. Constantly changing managers, he argued, does not solve the club's problems, and the responsibility does not fall on the players and coaching staff alone.

    His comments sparked wide controversy inside and outside the club. He later apologised for the timing and manner of his remarks, confirming that he had met the club's officials and manager Michael Carrick to exchange views about what had happened.

    A few weeks later, Martinez found himself in a completely different position. He became one of the most prominent reasons for Manchester United's 2-0 fall to Chelsea.

    Two bookings in a short space complicated his team's task. He was sent off in the 63rd minute following a challenge on Wesley Fofana inside the penalty area, and the referee awarded a penalty that Cole Palmer converted for the second goal. Martinez's problems did not stop at the dismissal. He also bore responsibility for the first goal, allowing Morgan Rogers to advance through United's defence before scoring at the start of the second half.

    Read also: Mourinho returns to the Racing stadium after 15 years: everything has changed except Barcelona's flag!

  • Martínez has become a burden: does he want to leave?

    Danny Murphy led the criticism of the Argentine defender. The former Liverpool and Tottenham midfielder reckons his recent conduct has gradually turned him into a "burden" on Manchester United, and he doubts whether the player can win back the trust of the coaching staff.

    Speaking on "Match of the Day", as reported by Metro, Murphy said: "Things are heading that way. A player with this experience and quality should have known what he was doing. It is clear that there is something not quite right with him at the moment, because you do not expect these poor performances from a player with such potential."

    He tied the sending-off to the troubles that came before it. There was the clash with Dominic Solanke against Tottenham, then the interview in which he criticised the club's management, and finally a display against Chelsea that Murphy branded well below his level.

    "I do not know whether he is thinking of leaving, or feeling upset about everything happening around the club, but he has put Carrick in a big dilemma now," he added.

    Murphy went even further. He ruled out the Argentine defender returning to the starting line-up once his suspension ends, saying: "I think it is unlikely that Michael will bring him back into the team, if he is still manager by then."

    Read also: commentator challenges Barcelona star's "haters": only Yamal, Raphinha and Mbappe can match him

  • United's crisis is bigger than any player

    Murphy's criticism of the Argentine defender was sharp, but he didn't let Carrick off the hook for Manchester United's stuttering start. The deeper problem, he reckoned, ran beyond a shortage of quality in certain positions, reaching into the physical and mental sides too.

    He said: "The biggest problem I see at Manchester United right now is not just a lack of quality. Over the past two months, the team has looked physically far from the level we saw at the end of last season."

    Poor physical preparation could be behind it, he added, or players switching off mentally and failing to respond to the manager's messages. For Murphy, it's a mix of both, varying from one player to the next.

    Can Carrick restore the team's cohesion, fighting spirit and physical levels with this group? Murphy wasn't convinced. And the pressure on the manager keeps building as the poor results pile up.

    Read also: Video: an indecent act: a disgraceful sending-off for the former Newcastle and Al-Ahly star

  • ENJOYED THIS STORY?

    Add GOAL.com as a preferred source on Google to see more of our reporting

    Follow GOAL on Google