Matlaba joined the Sea Robbers in 2012 from Free State Stars and became a key player for the Soweto giants.
He served the club for seven seasons and was appointed the captain following the exits of Siyabonga Sangweni and Oupa Manyisa.
Matlaba was one of the reliable leaders and players for Bucs during his time and served the club for several years, just as Jele did. Both defenders worked under Mokwena in 2019 and 2020 when the South African tactician was in charge on an interim basis.
Matlaba's exit then was linked with a contractual issue, but he has introduced a new twist into that by claiming the leadership at the club was the real problem.