MTN8 semi-final first leg: Can Mamelodi Sundowns rewrite their cup story at Orlando Pirates’ doorstep?

In the current two-legged MTN8 semi-final format, Pirates have never lost to Sundowns. They caricature cup success, having dispatched the visitors in 2011/12 (4–3 aggregate) and emphatically in 2022/23 (3–0) en route to lifting the silverware both times.   

These results birthed a narrative Sundowns have struggled to escape, their road to cup glory littered with Pirates’ scenes of dread. 

Meanwhile, Pirates’ recent MTN8 three-peat built an aura of inevitability when a draw brings these sides together. So when the draw happened, Sundowns faced not just a fixture, but a psychological exorcism. 

Pirates come into the semi-final with swagger rooted in cup pedigree, which, as history shows, they wield like a weapon. Yet, behind that confident façade lags concern. Their league trend has been rocky: back-to-back losses to Sekhukhune United and Marumo Gallants have dented early-season momentum.  

Still, at home in knockout football, they remain unbeaten in eight successive cup fixtures, an unmistakable source of psychological fuel, knowing Orlando Stadium is a cauldron where their cup ambitions ignite most fiercely. Their home advantage, backed by a boisterous sell-out crowd, is not just an environmental edge; it’s a narrative weapon.

Sundowns, on the other hand, seem reborn. Their MTN8 quarter-final performance, a 4–0 thrashing of Richards Bay, was not just a result but a sermon on their capability when firing on all cylinders. Their league campaign began with a 1–1 draw away at Chippa United, before a 2–0 victory over AmaZulu gave them their first full points.  

These early results hint at a team rediscovering its rhythm after the exhaustive end to last season, which included a grueling CAF Champions League final and a campaign at the FIFA Club World Cup. With departures such as ex-Buccaneer Thembinkosi Lorch and Neo Maema, the road ahead feels leaner but sharper. For the visitors, this isn’t underdog status; it’s calculated renaissance, led by a squad determined to reassert their dominance.

While the players will clash on the pitch, the real battle might be between the dugouts. Abdeslam Ouaddou faces the dual pressure of cup expectations and impatient fans, knowing that victory over Sundowns could cement his early legitimacy.    

For Miguel Cardoso, it’s about proving that Sundowns’ league dominance can be replicated in knockout football, while embedding his tactical identity in a team accustomed to a slightly different approach. 

The chess match will be tactical substitutions, in-game adjustments, and psychological nuance: Ouaddou must motivate a team under pressure, while Cardoso must ensure his squad maintains composure, controls possession and delivers a performance that reinforces belief in his evolving philosophy. This battle of minds could ultimately dictate the outcome of the first leg and set the tone for the return match in Tshwane.

For Pirates, a home victory would restore confidence, silence critics and keep momentum alive in their quest for a fourth consecutive MTN8 title. For Sundowns, even a draw with a goal would signal a shift in narrative, proving they can overcome historical cup obstacles and position themselves to strike decisively in the second leg. 

Beyond tactics and talent, this clash is about mentality, identity and leadership. Whoever emerges with the advantage on Saturday will have not just a scoreline but psychological dominance heading into the return leg.  

MTN8 page

Orlando Pirates page

Mamelodi Sundowns page