It was then that Carragher extended the banter, suggesting that Thierry Henry and host Kate Abdo should wear the Arsenal shirt next. Abdo quickly deflected the idea, saying, “No, I’m loyal.” When Carragher inquired who she was loyal to, she promptly responded, “To Manchester United, thank you very much,” referencing her favourite team.
The light banter took an uncomfortable turn when Carragher shot back, “You’re not loyal to Malik,” referencing Abdo’s then-boyfriend and now-husband, Malik Scott. The comment, made on live television, seemed to catch everyone off guard, and it quickly became clear that Carragher’s joke had missed the mark. The next day, Abdo delivered a sharp, witty comeback to bury the hatchet and said during her introduction: "Does [Carragher] go too far sometimes? Absolutely. Does he apologize? Yes, he does. But all of us have that one annoying family member that we still love.”