Exits to expectations: The departures that could reshape Mamelodi Sundowns and the gaps they need to fill

The Brazilians confirmed the departures of several players as part of their squad overhaul. These include defensive midfielder and centre-back Rivaldo Coetzee, who struggled with injuries, Sipho Mbule, who joined Orlando Pirates after an inconsistent spell at Chloorkop and Lucas Suarez, the Argentine defender who failed to make a lasting impact. 

Also heading out was Lebohang Maboe, whose career was hampered by injuries and Sifiso Ngobeni, another fullback making way, likely due to the arrival of Fawaaz Basadien. Forward Thabang Sibanyoni and goalkeeper Sanele Tshabalala have also departed, along with Kobamelo Kodisang, who returned to AVS Futebol SAD after his loan spell ended. Additionally, although not yet officially confirmed by the club, reports suggest that Brazilian forward Lucas Ribeiro is also on his way out, potentially to pursue a move abroad.

This list reflects not just a squad trim but a pivot towards a more focused, perhaps more youthful and strategically coherent approach under Cardoso.

With Coetzee and Mbule gone, the depth in the engine room suddenly looks thin in terms of both steel and creativity. While Teboho Mokoena and Marcelo Allende remain as midfield mainstays, Sundowns need a deeper-lying playmaker who can control tempo and dictate the game from the back, something Coetzee did when fit and was part of the team.

Additionally, a box-to-box midfielder who can contribute both defensively and in the final third would give Sundowns more tactical flexibility. The club may look to promote from within, but a high-quality addition, possibly even a foreign reinforcement, could be the answer to reinvigorating midfield transitions.

Losing Lucas Ribeiro, who has been a vital cog, would arguably be the biggest blow. His link-up play, ability to carry the ball through tight spaces and clinical finishing added another dimension to Sundowns’ attack.

Sundowns need a high-impact forward, preferably someone versatile who can operate across the front three. This is the marquee signing the club needs to prioritise if they are serious about challenging the continent’s elite once again.

The arrival of Fawaaz Basadien is a welcome addition, especially given the departure of Sifiso Ngobeni and the uncertain future of Terrence Mashego, who has battled injuries. Basadien brings a cultured left foot, solid defensive instincts and an attacking threat down the flank; he fits the Sundowns system perfectly.

However, on the right flank, Khuliso Mudau remains unrivalled. If he picks up an injury or suffers a dip in form, there’s a concerning lack of cover. Adding a right-sided wingback or fullback must be on the club’s radar to maintain their width and pressing intensity.

The exit of older players like Maboe and Coetzee and fringe players like Sibanyoni suggests a desire to refresh the squad. But Sundowns have been here before, stockpiling talent without integrating it smartly. 

Now, the challenge is to balance experience with the promise of youth, ensuring new signings contribute immediately while future stars are not left to rot on the bench.

Players like Cassius Mailula (if he returns), Ntando Nkosi and Siyabonga Mabena represent the club’s future, but they must be nurtured in a system that offers minutes and mentorship.

PSL page

Mamelodi Sundowns page

PSL transfer news