+18 | Commercial Content | T&C's Apply | Play Responsibly | Publishing Principles
Patrick Maswanganyi, Orlando PiratesOrlando Pirates

WATCH: Orlando Pirates benefited from poor officiating, but still lost as Patrick 'Maswanganyi is the one committing a foul' & Stellenbosch FC robbed in defeat to Kaizer Chiefs with ex-Fifa referee highlighting Sibongiseni Mthethwa's 'brutality'

Article continues below

Article continues below

Article continues below

  • Pirates awarded penalty after Maswanganyi foul
  • Mthethwa awarded yellow card after kicking opponent
  • The Safa Gauteng Referees boss gives his verdict
Follow GOAL on WhatsApp! 🟢📱
  • Former PSL referee Victor Hlungwani Backpage

    WHAT HAPPENED?

    Former Fifa referee Victor Hlungwani has given his verdict on the two controversial decisions that were made in last week's PSL matches.

    The 2011/12 PSL Referee of the Season is of the notion that Orlando Pirates were undeservedly awarded a penalty after Tshegofatso Nyama was adjudged to have fouled Patrick Maswanganyi in the box on January 8.

    However, Maswanganyi missed the resultant penalty and the Buccaneers went on to lose 1-0 as Darwin Gonzalez's 74th-minute goal earned Cape Town City the victory.

    Hlungwani also believes that Kaizer Chiefs should have been reduced to 10 players after Sibongiseni Mthethwa had kicked Sihle Nduli in the face, but the midfield hardman was only shown a yellow card in a match which saw Amakhosi claim a 2-1 win on January 8.

  • Advertisement
  • HLUNGWANI ON MASWANGANYI INCIDENT

    "Maswanganyi is the one committing a foul... He is the one jumping, impeding there," Hlungwani said on Soccer Zone.

    "He even stepped on top of Nyama there. This was not supposed to be a penalty, but it should have been a foul against Maswanganyi for fouling or impeding an opponent."

  • Sibongiseni Mthethwa, Kaizer Chiefs, November 2024Backpagepix

    HLUNGWANI ON MTHETHWA INCIDENT

    "Mthethwa is using what we call foot in the face, I don't know what he was thinking," Hlungwani said on Soccer Zone.

    "That is a red card. This is serious foul play, endangering the safety of an opponent. The player should be sent off. This is brutality.

    "So, the player should have been sent off for the foot in the face."

  • Wandile Duba, Kaizer Chiefs, January 2025Backpagepix

    WHAT NEXT FOR CHIEFS?

    Maswanganyi and his Pirates teammates are preparing for Saturday's clash against Al Ahly as the Buccaneers look to wrap up a successful Caf Champions League Group C campaign with a win.

    Mthethwa, on the other hand, will be hoping to help Chiefs bounce back to winning ways in the PSL when they square off with Sekhukhune United on Sunday.