Are you 24 or older?

Help us verify your age by providing an honest response. This site contains gambling advertising for 24+.

Age-restricted content

You’re not old enough to view betting content. You’ll be redirected to the homepage.

alt
Orlando City SC v FC Cincinnati: Eastern Conference Wild Card - Audi 2026 MLS Cup PlayoffsGetty Images Sport

MLS Winners and Losers: Evander sends Antoine Griezmann packing as gritty Real Salt Lake stun Seattle Sounders

Tom Hindle
  • That's the wildcard games sorted, then. And it seems as though there's a little bit of cosmic justice here. Cincinnati were better against Orlando, and walked away with a 3-1 win that really could have been eight. They are a more complete side, and even if there are massive question marks around their defense, they could be dangerous in moments against Nashville in the first round.

    Out West, it wasn't so cut and dry. But RSL delivered in the big moments, and Seattle did not. The Sounders missed a penalty in normal time, and then failed to convert repeatedly when spot-kicks were needed to settle things. RSL, meanwhile, scrapped, scrapped, and scrapped some more. Was that penalty win one for the statisticians? Not at all. But that's what playoff soccer is all about.

    Anyway, the playoff field is now entirely set, which means it's time for the fun stuff to really start. GOAL looks at the Winners and Losers of the wildcard fixtures...

  • WINNER: Evander

    Orlando City SC v FC Cincinnati: Eastern Conference Wild Card - Audi 2026 MLS Cup Playoffs
    Getty Images Sport

    Evander was at his brilliant best for Cincinnati against Orlando.

    Evander is an MVP finalist, yet it really feels like he's been well short of his best this season. FC Cincinnati fans have taken to blaming the Brazilian for their team's poor defensive record. In some ways, that's fair - off-ball work is usually a good thing. But pretending that Evander has ever been one for the hard graft is both incorrect and a bit silly.

    Indeed, Evander is here to kick the ball into the back of the net, and help others do the same. And on Thursday, it was that simple. Cincinnati scored three, and Evander had a hand in all of them. He bagged two, assisted the third, and made everything look remarkably easy. Even as his teammates were a bit wayward in the final third - seriously, this game should have been 5-1 - the Brazilian continued to provide. They are outmatched by Nashville, but Evander is a true difference-maker.

  • LOSER: Antoine Griezmann

    Orlando City SC v FC Cincinnati: Eastern Conference Wild Card - Audi 2026 MLS Cup Playoffs
    Getty Images Sport

    Griezmann failed to deliver, and Orlando City were sent home early.

    Antoine Griezmann told the press earlier this week that the play-in is very much not a playoff game. We can debate that in many, many words elsewhere. He's probably right, but perhaps the goalposts should be moved for Orlando, who sacked their manager just over a month into the season and looked to be going nowhere until Griezmann arrived. Indeed, he dragged this remarkably poor defense to a mid-table finish, which is no small feat.

    The problem? It all went a bit wrong Thursday night. It never quite came off for the Frenchman in attack. He created three chances, put a shot on target, and narrowly missed another. And even if he still found all sorts of pockets of space, Griezmann looked a player lacking sharpness after the international break. There will be other chances for him - and perhaps some activity from Orlando in the transfer market will do him some favors. But this was an unacrimonious playoff exit.

  • WINNER: Pablo Mastroeni

    Seattle Sounders FC v Real Salt Lake: Western Conference Wild Card - Audi 2026 MLS Cup Playoffs
    Getty Images Sport

    The RSL manager orchestrated a classy away win for RSL

    The RSL head coach has found the formula. In short? Make his team a real pest to play against. At the start of the season, this was a sexy football team, with Diego Luna and Zavier Gozo buzzing around, doing all sorts of fun things with the ball. But Gozo is gone, and Luna is out for the season with an injury.

    However, RSL have adapted wonderfully. Forget the attacking stuff - not entirely, but sorta - time to be a nightmare to play against. And yes, they afforded Seattle plenty of chances, but this was a gritty showing from Mastroeni's men, who went to Seattle, ground out a draw, and didn't miss a single penalty kick. It was their first win in 11 games at Seattle, and they have now won five of six. They are the in-form team in the West, and although Vancouver are clear faves, RSL are not to be sniffed at.

  • LOSER: Expected Goals

    Seattle Sounders FC v Real Salt Lake: Western Conference Wild Card - Audi 2026 MLS Cup Playoffs
    Getty Images Sport

    RSL overcame the stats in a testy away win.

    Well, you can take your stats and shove em.

    Seattle-RSL, in particular, was a massive game for the "football isn't played on a spreadsheet, mate" crowd. Here are some fun numbers. Seattle managed 19 shots. They put six on target. They amassed 3.19 expected goals, missed a penalty, and fell short when it came to spot kicks in the end. RSL, meanwhile, put two shots on target and scored one. They buried their one "big chance."

    The result? An RSL win on pens. Is this fair? Not really. If Albert Rusnak had buried his pen in the first half, the Sounders might have run away with it. But he didn't, and sometimes football works in mysterious ways. And that's a good thing.

  • Winner: Nashville SC

    FC Cincinnati v Nashville SC
    Getty Images Sport

    Nashville have an excellent record against FC Cincinnati this season.

    Well, it was always going to be tough for whoever played Nashville in the first round. They really are a juggernaut and should be considered outright favorites to win the whole thing. But FC Cincy have been a particularly favored opponent of theirs. They have beaten them twice already this season, by an aggregate score of 6-0.

    That's a tidy outcome for B.J. Callaghan's side, who picked up one of their three losses all season to Orlando back on July 25. Sure, that feels like ancient history now. But if they had to pick an opponent, odds are, they'd want FCC.

  • LOSER: Seattle's front office

    Seattle Sounders FC v Real Salt Lake: Western Conference Wild Card - Audi 2026 MLS Cup Playoffs
    Getty Images Sport

    The Sounders have been struck by injury at a number of key positions

    It feels like Seattle are due a proper refresh. Yes, Brian Schmetzer is a legend of a coach, who will always find ways to tweak his system. Yes, the Sounders have been hamstrung by injuries all season. But everyone has. This league is mightily unforgiving, and a World Cup year led to some quick turnarounds. Seattle, despite having quality and experience on the bench and in key positions, couldn't really cope.

    This feels like a pivotal moment, then. Seattle are 13th in average age of their roster in the league at 26.7, but that number has certainly been skewed by the number of young players Schmetzer has been forced to use. Here's the thing, though. Cristian Roldan is 31. Jordan Morris is 32 and injury-prone. Jackson Ragen might only be 28, but they need another option at center back. This is a team that deserves a bit of investment. Add a player or two and they could be right back in the mix again. Instead, it was a difficult season for a team that didn't quite have the on-field product.