Are you 24 or older?

Help us verify your age by providing an honest response. This site contains gambling advertising for 24+.

Age-restricted content

You’re not old enough to view betting content. You’ll be redirected to the homepage.

alt
Liverpool Anfield fear factor 1:1Getty/GOAL

How Liverpool lost their Anfield fear factor: Why the revamped Reds are still struggling to win games at home ahead of massive Man Utd showdown

Mark Doyle
  • Just a couple of months ago, the original 'This is Anfield' sign was brought back to Liverpool after two decades on display at a hotel on the Isle of Man. The mere fact that its return made the news tells you everything you need to know about the strength of the mythology surrounding the home of Liverpool Football Club.

    "To touch it again just feels so special," former Reds captain Phil Thompson said of the sign, which sold for £115,000 after being put up for auction by the family of former youth team player Ronald Wilson. "You can feel it, touch it, and sense the history of it."

    The original idea was for the sign to welcome opponents to Anfield, but Bill Shankly wanted to warn them, so he changed the wording.

    As the Scot once said, "When (former Newcastle United striker) Malcolm Macdonald first saw it, he turned to (coach) Joe Harvey and he joked, 'We've come to right ground so.'" But I said, 'Listen son, you'll soon find out what Anfield is about.' We beat them 5-0 that day and my opinion was that they were scared to death. Because Anfield is a terrible place to play. And I think that people are overawed by it." But maybe not anymore...

  • 'No marketing spin'

    Liverpool emblem
    Getty Images Sport

    Plenty of players past and present would attest to the remarkable power of Anfield to influence games

    Obviously, Liverpool have never been unbeatable at home - not even during their periods of sustained success under Shankly, Bob Paisley and Kenny Dalglish. Anfield nonetheless managed to retain its reputation as one of the most iconic and intimidating arenas in football, even after the Reds had been knocked off their perch in England by Manchester United.

    Sir Alex Ferguson repeatedly referred to the atmosphere as "electric" and "volatile", Arsene Wenger labelled it "unique", while both Gigi Buffon and Mikel Arteta admitted that Anfield was the one arena in which they felt completely disorientated by the deafening noise coming from the crowd.

    As former Manchester City manager Pep Guardiola said, "The motto ‘This is Anfield’ is no marketing spin. There’s something about it that you will find in no other stadium in the world. They score a goal and over the next five minutes you feel that you’ll receive another four. You feel small and the rival players seem to be all over you."

    Hardly surprising, then, that Jurgen Klopp made harnessing "the power of Anfield" his primary objective upon taking charge of Liverpool in 2015, and there's no denying that, over the following eight-and-a-half years, he successfully restored Anfield's fear factor - which helps explain why Virgil van Dijk didn't lose a single Premier League home game for the first four years of his time on Merseyside.

    Unfortunately for the Dutch defender, Liverpool's fortress has been repeatedly ransacked during the past year.

  • Tipping point

    Liverpool v Chelsea - Premier League
    Getty Images Sport

    Arne Slot won the title at the end of his first season at Anfield, but his days were numbered as soon as the fans lost faith in him

    The Kop played a pivotal part in Liverpool's surprise 2024-25 title triumph under former coach Arne Slot, as the Dutchman's team lost just one home game all season long, and only dropped points in four other outings. However, in the space of 10 days last winter, Liverpool suffered back-to-back three-goal losses at Anfield, against Nottingham Forest and PSV, before then being held to a 1-1 draw by newly-promoted Sunderland, meaning the Reds had failed to win three consecutive games at Anfield in all competitions since the Covid pandemic, when all matches were played behind closed doors.

    Slot openly conceded at the time that "teams that play us now think they can get a result", while Black Cats boss Regis Le Bris admitted that he couldn't believe how much "time and space to play" his team had been afforded. Slot clearly felt that he needed to stop the rot after a historically bad run of results, but his increasingly conservative tactics ultimately led to him being sacked just a year after winning the league.

    "There was one constant while I was watching and playing for Liverpool, irrespective of where we were in the table: when you play at Anfield, you respect no-one," former midfielder Danny Murphy recently told talkSPORT. "You have to go after your opponent and try to win the game. You have to do that. It's always been that way.

    "Last season was the first time in many, many years that teams had come to Anfield and dictated the game. Liverpool were playing counter-attacking football at home, and that's when the fans started to turn [against Slot]."

    The tipping point arguably arrived not after a defeat, but a desperately disappointing draw with a dreadful, relegation-threatened Tottenham team that prompted a chorus of boos from a crowd renowned for its patience.

    "I think there's a difference with most supporters in terms of what we see online compared to the match-going fans," former Reds defender Jamie Carragher said on Sky Sports. "It's not easy for a Liverpool crowd to turn on a manager who has won a title less than a year before, but I felt there was a big shift on Sunday in terms of how the crowd felt about the team and the manager. The booing at the end, that was proper booing from a disgruntled and unhappy fanbase. I think it's going to be really difficult now for Arne Slot. Once you lose that crowd, it's really difficult to get them back."

    And Carragher was right, with Slot sacked at the end of a torturous and trophy-less campaign that concluded with Liverpool limping home in fifth place in the Premier League after failing to win any of their final four games. However, while the atmosphere at Anfield has undoubtedly improved this season, the results have not.

  • 'Lost that little bit of belief'

    Liverpool v Arsenal FC - Premier League 2026/27
    Getty Images Sport

    Liverpool lost just once at home during their most recent title-winning season, but they've already been beaten twice there this term

    Liverpool are unquestionably favourites going into Sunday's showdown with Manchester United at Anfield. The visitors have had such an appalling start to the season that they elected to sack Michael Carrick during the international break and replace him with Mauricio Pochettino. However, while Liverpool sit fourth in the Premier League table, 14 places and 10 points above their visitors, the Reds' lofty position owes almost everything to their away form.

    No side has picked up more Premier League points on the road this season (13) - but Andoni Iraola's men have the third-worst home record in the league, having won just one of their five games so far, and scored a measly four times in the process.

    Obviously, the fans remain right behind the club's new Basque boss, given Iraola worked wonders in his previous role at Bournemouth and is only five months into his new job. However, former midfielder Paul Ince believes that the onus is very much on the coach - and his star players - to really give the crowd something to shout about in the coming days, weeks and months.

    "I've played in front of the Kop and Liverpool's a daunting place to go," the ex-England international told GOAL as part of his role with freebets.com. "I played there for two years, too, so I know what it's like, how you can intimidate teams. But when you look at Liverpool over the last two years, I think the fans have become a little bit despondent. Since Klopp left, they've kind of lost that passion, because Liverpool's so passionate and they're lovely people. They're great fans, but I think they've lost that little bit of belief.

    "Of course, it’s not just Liverpool - Man United are having the same problems, Man City are not as daunting as they were, even Arsenal struggled at home last time out against Hull. So, a lot of the lesser teams are coming to these places and feeling that they can get a result, and I think that's the case at Anfield. The only way you get that fear factor back is by winning games at home and beating teams by three or four, but Liverpool are not at that stage yet.

    "I think what they've got now, they've got a team that really is a work in progress. I don't think their players have really started flying yet. Florian Wirtz is one of them, Alexander Isak is another, there's a lot of players who have not quite fired at this moment in time."

  • Home discomforts

    Liverpool v Arsenal FC - Premier League 2026/27
    Getty Images Sport

    There are, however, grounds for optimism ahead of the visit of United. For starters, both Wirtz and Isak have impressed in recent weeks, with the former having backed up a productive display at Crystal Palace with three goals in two matches for Germany during the international break, while the latter, despite his worryingly small amount of touches during games, has scored more goals in the league this season (seven) than everyone bar Erling Haaland (nine).

    Iraola has also been at pains to point out that Liverpool have racked up some notable wins at home this season, most notably against Atletico Madrid in the Champions League, while beating Brighton should arguably be considered a major scalp given the Seagulls are flying high in second spot in the Premier League.

    What Iraola's Reds are undeniably lacking, though, is a statement win over a traditional rival in front of their own fans, given Liverpool have already lost at home this season to both Manchester City and Arsenal. Both defeats were tough to take from a purely historical perspective; after struggling for so long at Anfield, City have now triumphed on their last two visits, while Arsenal hadn't won there since Arteta's playing days. What was really disappointing from the supporters' perspective, though, was that their team failed to score in both games.

    Another shutout on Sunday would, thus, be a terrible look for an expensively assembled attack featuring three nine-figure footballers, with the summer arrival of the notoriously profligate Bradley Barcola having unsurprisingly failed to add a real cutting edge to a team that struggled dismally to find a way through low blocks last season. Consequently, while the narrative around the game centres on United, the result is unquestionably of far greater importance to Liverpool. For Pochettino, the game is essentially a free hit. For Iraola, though, it's a must-win.

    Because while the original 'This is Anfield' sign may be back on Merseyside, Liverpool's old fear factor most certainly is not - and losing to a United tean in crisis would only make it more difficult to get it back.