McElhenney was asked for his score prediction for the clash at the Racecourse Ground and he expected a 3-1 win for the Welsh side. He also called out co-owner Ryan Reynolds for never making pre-match predictions, saying: "He never guesses the score, I don't know why. I feel like there's no downside, you're either right or wrong. If you're right, you can celebrate. If you're wrong, you can pretend it didn't happen."
The It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia star was correct in predicting that Wrexham would win by two goals, but his team picked up a 2-0 victory instead of 3-1.