McElhenney has told The Athletic of making something with substance alongside Reynolds, with the pair still getting nervous in a production that involves no scripts: “You can turn on Disney, Hulu or Netflix and find hundreds, if not thousands, of documentaries on sports. Some are really engaging, but some are terrible and boring and seem as if it was a money grab instead of actually trying to tell a story.
“It’s really hard to have a camera shoved in your face all the time or to wear a microphone. People think that since you’re an actor, it must be easy. It really isn’t. It’s terrifying for us and for the players.
“The only way you’re going to get that level of authenticity is if you are willing to bare it all. There are plenty of times I’m sitting in an editing room and when I rewatch some footage, I sometimes look petulant or not like the kind of person that I would want to put out into the world. I realise if I don’t put that in the show, then people will smell that out. They will see this is inauthentic, that I’m creating some sort of propaganda piece.
“You can’t manipulate it. You can’t create it from nothing. If you ask the right questions and people are willing to give truthful answers to those questions, there’s a wellspring of stories in every community across the world. You just have to know how to tell it.”