+18 | Play Responsibly | T&C's Apply | Commercial Content | Publishing Principles
This page contains affiliate links. When you purchase through the links provided, we may earn a commission.
MLS Survey GFXGOAL

Who is the brightest star in MLS - and the most overrated? Best fan base, best coach, best city, area in which league must improve? GOAL surveyed players to find out

Major League Soccer's 30th season kicked off last weekend and it's already shaping up to its historic promise. San Diego FC entered the league and opened their expansion season by stunning the defending MLS Champions LA Galaxy.

There's been an unprecedented offseason of spending, with the league's transfer record broken twice. There's a new Cash for Player rule that's been significant in keeping stars within the league. And oh yeah, Inter Miami's Lionel Messi has kicked off the season with a masterclass performance and some rare controversy from the Eight-time Ballon D'Or winner.

As exciting as its been for MLS's fans, what do the players make of all of this? GOAL reached out to players from all 29 teams - excluding expansion San Diego - ahead of the 2025 season and asked them a number of questions, from naming the best and most overrated players to favorite MLS cities to coaches for which they would like to play. Players were granted anonymity so that they could answer freely.

And while some of the results from GOAL's MLS Player Survey were expected, others offered surprises.

  • Lionel Messi Miami 2025Getty

    WHO IS THE TOP PLAYER IN MLS?

    No surprise here, as Lionel Messi takes this by a significant margin. The 37-year-old received 88 percent of the vote from players polled, but - perhaps a bit shockingly - it wasn't unanimous.

    The other 12 percent came from the LA Galaxy's Riqui Puig and San Jose's Cristian Espinoza.

    The Vote Breakdown:

    Lionel Messi, Inter Miami, 88 percent

    Riqui Puig, LA Galaxy, 8 percent

    Cristian Espinoza, San Jose Earthquakes, 4 percent

  • Advertisement
  • Charlotte FC v Toronto FCGetty Images Sport

    WHO IS THE MOST OVERRATED PLAYER IN MLS?

    This one generated a wide variety of answers from players, but there was a top choice: Toronto FC's Lorenzo Insigne.

    The former Italy international was the second highest-paid player in MLS after Mess last year, but he hasn't delivered on massive expectations as injuries and inconsistent performances have impacted him. Toronto FC recently left the player off travel plans and have been open in saying he's not in their plan this season.

    The Vote Breakdown:

    Lorenzo Insigne, Toronto FC, 35 percent

    Kellyn Acosta, Chicago Fire, 20 percent

    Stefan Frei, Seattle Sounders, 10 percent

    Mikael Uhre, Philadelphia Union, 8.75 percent

    Roman Burki, St. Louis CITY SC, 8.75 percent

    Anders Dreyer, San Diego FC, 5 percent

    Some players declined to answer this question, with one writing, "Respect your friends and players."

  • TOPSHOT-US-MONUMENT-HOLLYWOOD-ANNIVERSARYAFP

    FAVORITE MLS CITY IN WHICH TO PLAY?

    Los Angeles was the leader when it came to cities in which MLS players prefer to play in, but there was some competition from up north.

    The Vote Breakdown:

    Los Angeles, 40 percent

    Montreal, 30 percent

    Nashville, 20 percent

    San Jose, 10 percent

  • FBL-USA-OPEN CUP-LAFC-SPORTING KCAFP

    WHICH MLS CLUB HAS THE BEST OPPOSING FANS?

    MLS fanbases have become famous across many cities' sporting landscapes. Again, Los Angeles - specifically LAFC - took the lead among players in terms of having the best opposing fans.

    The Vote Breakdown:

    Los Angeles FC, 50 percent

    Atlanta United FC, 20 percent

    Portland Timbers, 20 percent

    Austin FC, 10 percent

  • Los Angeles Football Club v Minnesota United FCGetty Images Sport

    WHICH IS THE BEST RUN TEAM IN MLS?

    Players were asked which team was the best run outside of their own organizations. LAFC again came out on top.

    The Vote Breakdown:

    LAFC, 41.6 percent

    Columbus Crew, 33.3 percent

    Seattle Sounders, 7.3 percent

    LA Galaxy, 7.3 percent

    In this category, 10.5 percent of the players surveyed were undecided.

  • Gabriel Pec LA galaxy 2024IMGAN

    WHAT'S MLS' GREATEST STRENGTH?

    Players were asked to provide written answers to this question. Here are some of the top responses:

    PLAYER: "Ownership spending mechanisms, bringing in new talent and ability to trade talent internally."

    PLAYER: "Clubs in good soccer markets, coast to coast."

    PLAYER: "Messi."

    PLAYER: "Opportunity for growth with World Cup in 2026."

    PLAYER: "International youth movement."

    PLAYER: "Excitement surrounding Messi and his friends being in the league."

    PLAYER: "Having Messi in the league."

    PLAYER: "Parity."

    Other responses highlighted diversity on the pitch, the work done by SUM marketing, and the overall infrastructure of the league.

  • Don Garber, MLSImagn

    WHAT DOES MLS NEED TO CHANGE?

    Players were also asked to provide written answers about areas in which the league can improve:

    PLAYER: "Get rid of the salary cap and get on the Euro calendar."

    PLAYER: "All teams need to be back in Open Cup. Cannot be a true 'Open Cup' without all teams in it."

    PLAYER: "We need free agency, get rid of draft and rookie deals with endless option years."

    PLAYER: "Salary Cap. Have a higher floor."

    PLAYER: "We need a shorter season."

    PLAYER: "Add player options in the contracts."

    PLAYER: "Playoff format."

    PLAYER: "Referees."
    PLAYER: "Calendar, salary cap, owners."

    PLAYER: "DP players."

    In addition, several players raised free agency as the biggest area in which MLS can improve - which could be an indicator of topic at the forefront of the next CBA negotiations between the league and players.

  • Wilfried NancyUSA Today

    WHICH MLS COACH WOULD YOU MOST LIKE TO PLAY FOR?

    Outside of their own managers, what coach would players most like to play for? The Crew's Wilfried Nancy, reigning MLS Coach of the Year, was the overwhelming choice - which shouldn't come as a surprise considering his success in Columbus.

    The Vote Breakdown:

    Wilfried Nancy, Columbus Crew: 50 percent

    Dean Smith, Charlotte FC: 8.3 percent

    Ben Olsen, Houston Dyanmo: 8.3 percent

    Bruce Arena, San Jose Earthquates: 8.3 percent

    Javier Mascherano, Inter Miami: 8.3 percent

    In this category, 8.3 percent of players said "not sure."

  • Hirving Lozano, Anders Dreyer, San Diego FCImagn

    ARE YOU EXCITED ABOUT THE ADDITION OF SAN DIEGO?

    The sentiment was overwhelmingly positive regarding the expansion franchise.

    The Vote Breakdown:

    YES: 91.7 percent

    NO: 8.3 percent

  • The Mirage Hotel & Casino Closes In Las VegasGetty Images News

    WHAT'S MARKET MLS SHOULD CONSIDER FOR EXPANSION?

    MLS is always evaluating potential new markets as the league continues to grow and expand, now expanded to 30 teams. Here is where players think the league should look next.

    The Vote Breakdown:

    Las Vegas: 41.6 percent

    Phoenix: 33.3 percent

    Tulsa, Oklahoma: 8.3 percent

    Interestingly, 16.6 percent of the players said "none" when asked about the next market.