+18 | Play Responsibly | T&C's Apply | Commercial Content | Publishing Principles
This page contains affiliate links. When you purchase through the links provided, we may earn a commission.
Eastern Conference GradesGOAL

MLS Eastern Conference midseason grades: Lionel Messi's Inter Miami and Evander's FC Cincinnati make push for the top, concerns mount for Atlanta United

The MLS All-Star Game is next week, marking the unofficial midpoint of the 2025 campaign. Most teams have now played 23 regular-season matches (with a few exceptions), and the league’s landscape is starting to take shape. In a highly competitive Eastern Conference, there have been plenty of positive surprises - from Tai Baribo's Philadelphia Union to Hany Mukhtar's Nashville SC. Contenders like Inter Miami and FC Cincinnati have also come back stronger than before. But there have been disappointments, too, ranging from big-spenders like Atlanta United to more frugal clubs such as CF Montréal and D.C. United.

Now, with the summer transfer window opening in exactly one week, the stakes are rising. It’s the last real opportunity for clubs to bolster their rosters ahead of the final push - whether chasing regular-season silverware or scrambling for a playoff spot. So, where does each team stand heading into the window, and how have they performed so far?

GOAL grades each Eastern Conference team as the second window arrives and the final stretch of the campaign sits on the horizon.

  • Miguel Almiron Atlanta United 2025Imagn

    Atlanta United: D

    Current standing: 13th place

    Season so far: Woof, Atlanta.

    The league's highest-spending team in transfer fees in 2025, the Five Stripes have underwhelmed in every department this season. They hired a former MLS Cup winner in manager Ronny Deila to lead them this campaign, and nothing has gone to plan. They spent an MLS-record amount of money on striker Emmanuel Latte Lath, only for the Ivorian to sit on six goals in 21 appearances, while club legend Miguel Almiron returned as well, but has yet to find his groove, either.

    Atlanta have a lot of pieces, but there's no puzzle to put them into right now. They're just pieces thrown together, with no shape or design.

    As it stands, they're not going to the postseason, and that's a shocking statement considering the investment behind the team.

    Major moves:

    + Brought Miguel Almiron in from Newcastle United

    + Signed Emmanuel Latte Lath from Middlesbrough for an MLS-record fee

  • Advertisement
  • Inter Miami CF v Charlotte FCGetty Images Sport

    Charlotte FC: B

    Current standing: Ninth place

    Season so far: Charlotte started the campaign out in blistering form, competing with the best in the East, but they've fallen off over the past two months. Injuries have plagued them at times, while international call-ups really hurt them in June, but Dean Smith is still figuring out how to get the most out of this squad.

    Wilfried Zaha hasn't quite had the attacking impact many expected, while inconsistent performances in all areas of the pitch have them sitting in the area of really good to really bad at times. This team, at times, has been the best version of Charlotte since their first season in 2022. But they certainly need more consistency.

    Major moves:

    + Signed Wilfried Zaha on loan from Galatasaray

    + Sold Patrick Agyemang to Derby County

  • Chicago Fire FC v D.C. UnitedGetty Images Sport

    Chicago Fire: B-

    Current standing: 10th place

    Season so far: The Fire were arguably MLS' most ambitious team ahead of the 2025 season. They were reportedly in talks to bring Neymar to MLS, and then explored a deal to potentially land Kevin De Bruyne this summer. Although neither worked out, they have to be commended for their efforts.

    As for their performances this campaign, they have had moments of absolute brilliance this season, but there have also had periods of play where inexcusable individual errors have haunted them. It's been up and down for Gregg Berhalter's men, but the positives have outweighed the negatives in terms of big picture.

    The Fire are relevant once again, and it's thrilling to see one of MLS's biggest markets back in the playoff hunt.

    Major moves:

    + Brought in Jonathan Bamba as a DP winger

    + Acquired Philip Zinckernagel from Cercle Brugge

  • FC Cincinnati: A

    Current standing: Second place

    Season so far: Cincy have had a blistering start to 2025. Ahead of the season, Pat Noonan made a major gamble in trading Lucho Acosta, but bringing in Evander from the Timbers was a master stroke. It has proved to be the move needed to bring them to the tier of elite teams across MLS. FCC is one of the most cohesive squads in the league, playing a brilliant back-five system focused on counter-attacking through possession.

    As things stand, FCC are contenders for the Eastern Conference title, Supporters' Shield, and MLS Cup. They're doing everything right, and their Brazilian talisman is spearheading what is looking like a special campaign.

    Major moves:

    + Traded for Evander from Portland, sent Lucho Acosta to FC Dallas

    + Brought in striker Kevin Denkey from Cercle Brugge

  • Columbus Crew: B+

    Current standing: Fourth place

    Season so far: Columbus have arguably been MLS's most consistent team over the past three seasons, including their 2025 campaign. They've been right in the thick of the conversation for contending for multiple trophies this season, and have put forth some splendid performances. The club has obviously missed a pure natural goalscorer since Cucho Hernandez's departure, but they've done well to navigate the waters without him.

    Manager Wilfried Nancy has pulled off some big performances, but there have also been moments where the club has underwhelmed, particularly in the month of May, when they won just once. A big summer transfer window awaits, as rumors of them adding a new DP lurk.

    Major moves:

    + Sold Cucho Hernandez to Real Betis in Spain

    + Traded for Daniel Gazdag from Philadelphia Union

  • FBL-EUR-C3-SERVETTE-SHERIFFAFP

    D.C. United: D

    Current standing: 14th place

    Season so far: The 2025 season has been nothing short of a disaster for United. Striker Christian Benteke has missed over one-third of the campaign so far due to injury, and they failed to bring in any marquee additions to bolster their squad ahead of the campaign. The lone bright spot for them this season has been Gabriel Priani, but the Brazilian himself only has seven goal contributions to his name this season.

    They fired Troy Lesesne last week and have since brought in Rene Weiler to fill his shoes. It's an uphill battle to make anything of this season, meaning this is now a roughly four-month stretch of preparing for 2026 under the new manager.

    Major moves:

    + Fired head coach Troy Lesesne

  • Inter Miami: B+

    Current standing: Fifth place

    Season so far: Inter Miami, and Lionel Messi in particular, had an unusually slow start to the season. Immediately, questions rose about their competitive level, especially with their early exit from the Champions Cup. However, their performance at the FIFA Club World Cup this summer was nothing short of admirable, and they've returned to the fray with a few unbelievable performances of late.

    Messi looks like a prime candidate for MVP again, and some of the offseason additions to the squad are really making an impact, in particular, Tadeo Allende and Maxi Falcon. Where Miami have fallen short, though, is depth. They have no true striker option that Javier Mascherano trusts besides Luis Suarez, and their fullback and centerback options still are not up to par with the league's elite.

    A big transfer window looms, though, with talks of a reported deal for Argentina international Rodrigo De Paul in the works. If he joins, Miami will immediately be looked at as the frontrunners in the East.

    Major moves:

    + Signed defender Maxi Falcon from Colo Colo

    + Added attackers Tadeo Allende, Telasco Segovia to the squad

  • Houston Dynamo FC v CF MontrealGetty Images Sport

    CF Montreal: D+

    Current standing: 15th place

    Season so far: Montreal fired manager Laurent Courtois five matches into the season, and that's roughly been a summary of how things have gone in 2025. They sit last in the East and Supporters' Shield standings, having won just three total matches this season. They still don't have a permanent head coach, and the front office has yet to lay out a framework or plan of how the Canadian side can bounce back to relevancy in 2025.

    One of the few bright spots for them this season, however, has been their resiliency on the road. They've taken results in five of their 13 road games this season, which, by all accounts, is impressive given their current situation.

    Major moves:

    + Brought in MLS Cup-winner Jalen Neal from LA Galaxy

    + Signed teenage prospect Hennadii Synchuk

  • Nashville SC v New England RevolutionGetty Images Sport

    Nashville SC: A

    Current standing: Third place

    Season so far: What an absolutely outrageous season from Nashville so far. They're the big surprise of the East this season, and manager B.J. Callaghan has them playing some of the most competitive soccer across the entire league.

    Striker Sam Surridge leads the league in scoring with 17 goals, while former league MVP Hany Mukhtar looks to be back to his best, playing his best soccer since his 2022 award-winning season. The third-highest scoring team in the conference, Nashville SC are right in the mix for a conference title and the race for a Supporters' Shield.

    Major moves:

    + Signed defender Andy Najar from CD Olimpia

  • Nashville SC v New England RevolutionGetty Images Sport

    New England Revolution: C-

    Current standing: 11th place

    Season so far: Caleb Porter's squad has not had the start to 2025 that they had hoped. The former two-time MLS Cup-winning manager turned his roster over this offseason, bringing in what was nearly an entirely different XI of players from last year, and things just haven't gone to plan.

    Club legend Carles Gil has been brilliant this season, playing at a caliber above everyone else in the team, but that's been the key issue - nobody is up to par with the level needed to compete with the best in MLS outside of their Spanish talisman. The Revs are just falling short, everywhere, including on the touchline with their manager.

    Porter has the hottest seat in MLS at the moment, and New England have a big decision to make this summer, determining if they hold onto him.

    Major moves:

    + Traded for Leonardo Campana from Inter Miami

    + Transferred Noel Buck to San Jose Earthquakes

  • Charlotte FC v New York City FCGetty Images Sport

    New York City FC: C

    Current standing: Seventh place

    Season so far: NYCFC were in an odd place heading into 2025, and midway through the campaign, are still in the same spot. They lost both James Sands and Santi Rodriguez to transfers ahead of the season, and only had one rostered DP to begin the season in Thiago Martins. With a relatively young and inexperienced team, it wasn't known what the Pigeons would bring this season, and six months in, we still don't know a ton, to be honest.

    They're mid-table, competing every week and playing some very good soccer, but their roster isn't to the standard of the best in the East. Their front office probably knows that and took action, recently bringing in an attacking DP in Nicolás Fernández Mercau. The former Elche star might be the key to them pushing for a higher seed in the playoffs.

    Major moves:

    + Sold Santiago Rodriguez to Botafogo

    + Loaned James Sands to St. Pauli in Germany

    + Added new DP Nicolás Fernández Mercau in July

  • D.C. United v New York Red BullsGetty Images Sport

    New York Red Bulls: C

    Current standing: Eighth place

    Season so far: Reigning MLS Cup runners-up, RBNY has not started 2025 the way they'd hoped. Sure, they're in a playoff spot as things stand, but it's been bleak inconsistency in all areas of the pitch for them this season. If they didn't have Emil Forsberg pulling the strings in the midfield, they'd be completely lost centrally and in the attack, as the likes of both Eric Maxim Choupo-Moting and Mohammed Sofo rely heavily on his presence beneath them.

    The Red Bulls need another attacking creator who can alleviate some of the stress on Forsberg this summer, or they'll continue stagnating in the middle of the table, competing for a low-end playoff spot. They've been linked with a move for Timo Werner, but nothing has come from it beyond reported talks. As it stands, last years finalists don't look close to coming close to replicating their postseason heroics.

    Major moves:

    + Transferred defender John Tolkin to Holstein Kiel

    + Signed striker Wiktor Bogacz from Miedz Legnica

  • Inter Miami CF v Orlando CityGetty Images Sport

    Orlando City: B-

    Current standing: Sixth place

    Season so far: Orlando have been consistently good. They're not contenders just yet, but they're among the better sides in the Eastern Conference, and it's primarily due to some really good offseason business from the club. Winger Marco Pasalic has been a revelation in their attack, with 14 goal contributions in his debut season for the club so far. His presence has also brought the best out of Martin Ojeda, who is already in double-digits for both goals and assists for the club this season.

    However, where they've found brilliance, there have also been shortcomings. Striker Duncan McGuire has been sidelined with an injury that has him out for quite some time still, and fellow forward Luis Muriel has been incredibly inconsistent in front of net. They've lacked a lethal No. 9 all season, and it's hurt them in games where results were there for the taking.

    As it stands, Orlando won't win any regular-season silverware, but they could be a sneaky good playoff team. This group has the skeleton to compete in the playoffs, and one or two more additions this transfer window could be the moves that get them over the line in November.

    Major moves:

    + Signed Eduard Atuesta from Palmeiras

    + Signed forward Marco Pasalic from HNK Rijeka

  • Philadelphia Union v D.C. UnitedGetty Images Sport

    Philadelphia Union: A

    Current standing: First place

    Season so far: What a season so far from the Union. Bradley Carnell was appointed head coach ahead of the campaign, and he has been massive on the touchline for Philadelphia. The Union are atop the Supporters' Shield standings and the conference, and look infinitely better than the group who underwhelmed towards the end of the 2024 season.

    Striker Tai Baribo has been lights-out in front of net, and is having a career year in terms of goalscoring for the club. Meanwhile, the entire group has bought in on the tactical setup of Carnell, and they're producing at an exceptional rate as a result.

    It's been near perfect from Philly all season, and this run has them sitting as prime contenders for both regular-season and postseason silverware.

    Major moves:

    + Traded midfielder Jack McGlynn to Houston Dynamo

    + Traded forward Daniel Gazdag to Columbus Crew

    + Acquired forward Bruno Damiani from Nacional

  • Toronto FC v Chicago Fire FCGetty Images Sport

    Toronto FC: C

    Current standing: 12th place

    Season so far: Listen, we all know performances on the pitch from Toronto have left a lot to be desired.

    However, TFC have been handed what really is a fresh start after buying out the contracts of Bernardeschi and Insigne. They have open DP slots, salary cap flexibility, and a few pieces to use as backbones on their roster as manager Robin Fraser now really gets to build out his team.

    Right now, TFC are preparing for 2026 - the current campaign is practically a wash, and everyone in the club knows that, but building the skeleton of the team out for 2026 begins now. This upcoming transfer window will be crucial.

    Major moves:

    + Utilized contract buyouts on Lorenzo Insigne and Federico Bernardeschi