In May 2023, Press appeared on ESPN show Futbol Americas and gave a positive update on her recovery, saying she was "in the final stretch" of it. However, just two months later, the Angel City star shared some devastating news on Instagram as she revealed that she needed a fourth ACL surgery in just 13 months.
"I know I've given every ounce of my being to making it back. I also trust that I am exactly where I'm supposed to be," she wrote in an open statement. "For me, the hardest part of recovery has been that I feel misunderstood. In fact, I feel un-understandable.
"I'm not anxious to get back on the field. My identity isn't lost by not playing. Most days, I don't even miss it. But that doesn't mean I don't want to get back. That I'm not working every second of every day to return to the pitch. That hard [part] is: I don't know what it does mean. My days are mostly good. I'm working toward my goal. And despite the fact that, on paper, this is an athlete's recovery nightmare, I feel in my heart that to climb the mountain - yes, even one more time - is the dream."
Press finally made her long-awaited return to the field on August 2, as a substitute in Angel City's penalty shootout win over the San Diego Wave in the NWSL x Liga MX Femenil Summer Cup. The 35-year-old scored her spot-kick in the victory after making her first appearance for club or country in 781 days.