However, Carragher refused to back down and humorously alluded to Messi's unwillingness to appear alongside him as a "claim to fame." He then went on to question whether the crowd would prefer his analysis or the presence of the football icon on CBS. Although the crowd backed Carragher, Abdo did not believe them and suggested that the studio audience was lying.
Nonetheless, Messi's recent impact on Inter Miami and American football, notably leading his team to the US Open Cup finals and securing their first-ever Leagues Cup victory, would likely make CBS more interested in having Messi appear on their broadcast.