Shortly after the capture of Owen, Real raided the Premier League for another English star, snapping up Jonathan Woodgate from Newcastle for £13m. "No one is pleased that he’s gone because we know what we’ve lost. At his best, he’s the best in the country," Magpies boss Sir Bobby Robson said after his departure.
In truth, Woodgate never really got the chance to show his quality at St James' Park. He established himself among English football's elite defenders at Leeds United, but his 18-month spell at Newcastle was overshadowed by injury.
Critics couldn't understand why Real were taking the gamble on Woodgate, who wasn't even known to a large portion of the Spanish media before his transfer to the Bernabeu. It was something of a miracle that he was even able to pass his medical, as he touched down in Spain nursing a torn thigh muscle, but Perez insisted “he’ll be playing within three weeks”. That statement turned out to be a kiss of death, as Woodgate sat out the entire 2004-05 campaign after numerous setbacks with his recovery.
Woodgate finally returned to full fitness over the summer, and made his long-awaited debut for Real on September 22, 2005 against Athletic Club, some 17 months after his last competitive appearance. Lining up alongside Francisco Pavon in the heart of the defence in front of a packed-out Bernabeu crowd, the nerves would surely have been great for Woodgate. But few would have expected them to consume him quite so spectacularly.
Twenty-five minutes into the contest, Joseba Etxeberria cut in from the left before unleashing a shot from the far corner of the box, which looked to be heading wide - until Woodgate threw himself at the ball and diverted a header past a helpless Iker Casillas in the Real net. Woodgate then picked up a yellow card for a rash tackle on Carlos Gurpegi before the break, which set the stage for the completion of the former Newcastle star's waking nightmare.
Robinho netted an equaliser for Real before Raul put them in front, but Woodgate gave Athletic hope when he picked up another booking, this time for throwing his forearm into Etxeberria's face. Los Blancos managed to grind out a 3-1 win despite Woodgate's horror show, but he would never live it down.
Woodgate would only feature in 13 more games for Real as injuries continued to plague him, and was voted the worst signing of the 21st century by readers of Spanish newspaper Marca after his exit in 2007.