Are you 24 or older?

Help us verify your age by providing an honest response. This site contains gambling advertising for 24+.

Age-restricted content

You’re not old enough to view betting content. You’ll be redirected to the homepage.

alt
Nashville 1-1GOAL

'We're not afraid to talk about our ambitions' - How B.J. Callaghan’s Nashville SC went from expansion 'afterthought' to MLS record-breakers chasing the double

Tom Hindle
  • It's a strange week for B.J. Callaghan. Even he, among the most outwardly present of MLS coaches, can admit that. And no, it's not because of outside noise due to a certain job opening that has suddenly popped up.

    Rather, his Nashville SC side, after setting an MLS points record (77), winning the Supporters' Shield, and cruising their way through the regular season, are caught in stasis a little bit. At the time of talking, a handful of his players are off with their national sides. Those that are around have been given an extra day off. Nashville knew, on Oct. 24, that they would hold the No.1 seed in the East. They might have suspected it before then - even if this team seldom allows itself to reflect on the bigger picture. The energy, the week-in, week-out tumble of a record-setting regular season, has been put on hold.

    "It's a unique sort of situation to be in," Callaghan told GOAL. "But everybody's in kind of the same boat."

    What it does provide, though, is a rare moment of sincere reflection - but not in a typical way. This is not a chance, necessarily, for a party, or weeks on the beach. Rather, Callaghan and his staff have treated it as time for thorough evaluation. Nashville have pieced together a record-breaking regular season. They lived it. They ground out the results and did all of the little pieces every single day that make a winning team.

    Now, on the eve of the playoffs, they are asking the question that so many Supporters' Shield winners have failed to answer:

    How do we turn a regular season triumph into an MLS Cup win?

    "We're really proud of the body of work that we were able to put together," Callaghan said. "We're proud that we were able to break so many records. And when we talk about the reflection, we look back at what the things are that made those things possible, right? And that's where we get into the details."

  • 'All everyone talked about was David Beckham'

    Inter Miami CF Media Availability & Training Session
    Getty Images Sport

    Beckham's Inter Miami were the shiny new team when they arrived in MLS in 2020, the same year Nashville did.

    In 2020, MLS introduced two expansion franchises. The first - and the one that, no doubt, grabbed the most headlines - was Inter Miami. Here was David Beckham's team, given full form, pink jerseys and all. The second - cast by some as the other guys - was Nashville. That perception, one of Nashville being the awkward little brother to the glitzier South Florida outfit, used to really annoy higher-ups at the club.

    "All everyone talked about was David Beckham, South Florida, Miami, and them being more glamorous," GM Mike Jacobs told GOAL. "We were almost like an afterthought. So I found that I was very contentious. I was in the media, defending our club, like 'Hey, we're really good too.'"

    But then, while Miami struggled - at least, at first - Nashville steadily built up something that looks far more sustainable. According to Spotrac, Nashville have the ninth-highest payroll in MLS. Despite that, they ran away with the East.

    "We've demonstrated against the best teams in our league and the highest-paying teams in our league that we can punch above our weight, you know. But that weight or expectation? That's outside of our locker room. That's media. From our standpoint, we always believe that we're capable of competing with and beating the top teams in MLS in North America," Jacobs said.

    And now, after six years of harder graft with an admittedly smaller brand, the proof is in the league table.

    "Everybody wants to be good. They want to be looked at for doing their job well. I'm just maybe self-aware enough or self-confident enough. I just know we're doing a good job. I don't have to worry about whether people think we're doing a good job or not," Jacobs said.

    In truth, it's been hard work. Nashville’s squad had been together for all of five weeks when they lost their MLS debut 2–1 to Atlanta United, the 2018 MLS Cup champions. By 2023, Nashville had reached the Leagues Cup final and taken Inter Miami to the 11th round of penalties before falling short. They took a step back in 2024, then returned to the playoffs in 2025 and pushed Miami to a deciding third game in the first round. This year marks Nashville’s sixth playoff appearance in seven MLS seasons.

    Something was growing. They just didn't know how big it could be.

  • 'We have all of our chips ready'

    Nashville SC v Chicago Fire FC
    Getty Images Sport

    Callaghan's tactical nous has been key this season.

    So, yes, this has been a journey. In 2025, a U.S. Open Cup win served as a nice bit of validation - and a long-awaited first trophy in club history. But even before they lifted that silverware, back in October 2025, conversations were underway about next season. Scouting, player identification, thinking about systems: those things had been ticking away since the start of the campaign.

    For Jacobs, the key was flexibility. MLS roster rules are restrictive. He wanted to ensure that, should an ideal free agent crop up, Nashville had the ability to strike. One such player was Cristian Espinoza. An outright star for the San Jose Quakes, it became clear over the summer that there was a chance he would be available in December as a free agent.

    "We wanted to be in a situation where if a player like Cristian became available, we'd be ready to strike... we want to make sure we were in a position that we have all our chips ready to kind of push in the middle of the table," Jacobs said.

    Espinoza was sitting in his agent's office in Buenos Aires when the phone rang. Soccer was on the TV. The two of them were just talking about the game. It was, in general, a fairly innocuous day. Nashville was on the line, his agent said. Espinoza had a couple of friends who had played there, and, in truth, he wanted to hear from as many clubs as possible.

    "I was open to hearing as many offers as I can, so then I can choose properly. I need to think about it because at this point in my career, I really want to go to a place where I can fight for titles and compete for every tournament," Espinoza explained to GOAL.

    Jacobs' pitch lasted a few minutes. And then came Callaghan, with a detailed breakdown of how, exactly, Espinoza would fit into Nashville's side.

    "I remember [Callaghan] took over, and he was really prepared. He had a bunch of videos of my games and other videos. He showed me movements that he saw me in his team playing and doing. So he was really prepared," Espinoza said. "For me it was really special because when I spoke to other clubs, I only spoke to GMs. With Nashville, it was the very first time that I spoke straight with the coach, and the coach showed me his ideas."

    For Callaghan, that's just standard practice:

    "We try to give players as much clarity as possible, and to define their roles and responsibilities as clearly as possible, and then that allows us to work together to continue to help them develop in those areas," he said.

    Right there, Espinoza's mind was made up. He called his wife and opened the conversation with one statement:

    "We are going to Nashville."

  • 'This is the level I need to be at'

    Nashville SC v Chicago Fire FC
    Getty Images Sport

    Espinoza's 15 assists helped carry Nashville to a Supporters' Shield win

    Espinoza was not the only signing of the offseason. But he was, no doubt, the most recognizable and also the most expensive. Nashville are paying him DP money, shelling out around $2 million per year for the Argentine playmaker.

    And the first thing he noticed was the intensity. In his first training session, two teammates went in for a tackle, full-blooded in a pretty standard scrimmage game. Espinoza froze for a second, watching the two of them in a heap on the ground. Without hesitation, both of them got up and continued with practice.

    "They get up without saying anything, shake hands, and keep moving, keep going forward. I said, 'Okay, this is the level that I need to be prepared for, because the intensity was really high, and that's the way that we play," Espinoza said.

    Callaghan does not remember the exact tackle. But it adds up for him.

    "Training is competitive, and we want it to be competitive. And not only do we want it to be competitive because we want guys that want to play, but we also believe that that's what prepares guys for whatever role that they're provided," he said.

    That mentality certainly seems to have brought life out of the Argentine attacker. In truth, Nashville needed a third weapon. The Hany Mukhtar-Sam Surridge duo is one of the most effective in MLS. But having another option? That has taken the team to another level. The stats back ot up, too. Espinoza tallied 15 assists this year, a career best.

     Espinoza wasn’t the only newcomer to make an impact. Maxwell Woledzi, the 2026 MLS Defender of the Year, gave Nashville more solidity in central defense. Reed Baker-Whiting stood out at left back and made his senior USMNT debut against Haiti on Nov. 17. Elias Saad added another option in attack after arriving on loan from Augsburg in July.

    Nashville tied the MLS record with 17 clean sheets and conceded just 25 goals, the fewest by any MLS team in a 34-game season. At the other end, only Inter Miami and Vancouver scored more than Nashville’s 71 league goals.

    "A ton of credit needs to go to BJ, but also to the front office for being able to go out in the transfer market and add to this team, add the quality that they needed - I think to make them one of the elite teams in Major League Soccer," Dax McCarty said in a recent Apple TV media session.

  • 'We talk about ambition'

    FC Cincinnati v Nashville SC
    Getty Images Sport

    Nashville haven't taken their foot off the gas - despite wrapping up the Eastern conference early

    The key, though, comes from the coaching staff. Jacobs can recruit all he wants - and execute at a high level with cap space, trading and free agency. Espinoza can provide the assists. Surridge can find the net (only Petar Musa and Leo Messi scored more this year). But Callaghan has perhaps been the real revelation here.

    Nashville knew what they were getting, Jacobs said. Callaghan appealed largely due to his willingness to work with young players at the Union academy. He developed a teenager named Brendan Aaronson, who went on to nudge highly-paid DP Marco Fabián out of the side.

    "What kind of sold me on BJ was his experiences in Philadelphia when he was an assistant there. He had a really brave way to play young kids," Jacobs said.

    Nashville might be the more experienced side at this point. But Callaghan put Aaronson in all of the right places to break into the first team. It was development, tactics and dedicated coaching. That mentality has never left, really. And it has carried him - and Nashville - here. To be sure, coaches are happy to talk about details. But get Callaghan started on team structures? The minutiae flow out with ease.

    There's the attack:

    "For us, it's still making sure that our attack is balanced. So finding new ways and creative ways and different ways to get the ball from one side to the other - I think that's always an important piece for us."

    And then, there's solving problems in defense, too:

    "We always start kind of from our mid block, and then how can we improve the ways that we're pressing and pressing through to the goalkeeper? And then we spend a lot of time talking about our position when we have the ball, so we can immediately press after loss, or if we get broken, how do we recover into a low block."

    Soccer loves a story about the lengths a coach will go to get a message across. At Arsenal, Mikel Arteta has turned to olive trees, a training-ground dog and even professional pickpockets.

    Callaghan obsesses over where his players stand while Nashville still have the ball. Get that right, and they can press the moment they lose it. If opponents play through the press, they can drop into a compact shape. Even after a 77-point season, Callaghan is asking how they can get sharper in those moments. Get complacent for a second, and MLS will eat you alive.

    Nashville allow themselves to think about loftier goals, but only for a second before delving back into the details.

    "We're not afraid to talk about our ambitions. We don't act like we don't have ambitions. We talk about what our ambition is going to be, and then we quickly refocus on what the steps are that we need to take, and what commitments we need to make to each other to achieve these things. That's what process means," Callaghan said.

  • 'We just roll our sleeves up'

    Nashville SC v Sporting Kansas City
    Getty Images Sport

    Callaghan's Nashville have set countless MLS regular season records this year.

    That habit of asking what could be better has brought Nashville this far.

    "With anything. It takes time to see, and you have to be committed to stick with it," Callaghan said. "If you're trying to lose weight, you're not going to lose weight in a week. Or if you're trying to build muscle, you're not going to do it in a week. You have to believe in your plan, and you have to kind of stick with it. But at the same time, you do have to reflect and refine it."

    That means little time to celebrate or commiserate.

    "We always talk about trying to stay emotionally neutral with the group. Right after a win, we go up a notch for 12 or 18 hours. If we lose a game, we can feel bad. But then we try to get right back to neutral and go right back into our preparation," Callaghan said.

    The wait for an opponent is one more test of that routine. Nashville open their best-of-three series at GEODIS Park on Sunday, Nov. 22, against the winner of Thursday’s Wild Card game between Orlando City and FC Cincinnati. Callaghan and his staff have started preparing for both.

    Sound a bit much? That's just how this team works. And it's served them well so far.

    “We keep rolling up our sleeves,” Callaghan said. “And getting to work.”