TH: In the modern era, certainly. Others have scored more goals throughout their careers, but Morgan has been a constant through multiple iterations of the U.S. game, and still found the back of the net as other countries have become more of a threat. There's also something to be said for influence. A lot of kids grew up wanting to be "the next Alex Morgan" because of the way she consistently performed for her country. Throw in the impressive trophy cabinet and the considerable off-field work and you've got a pretty good case.
As for Smith, ask us in 10 years. But she certainly has the talent to make it happen. For her, it seems a question of piecing it all together on the biggest stage - she still hasn't quite found consistency in a U.S. jersey.
RT: Morgan is on the Mount Rushmore for the USWNT, but there are just so many contenders, right? Abby Wambach and Mia Hamm probably have better cases, but, depending on your generation, you could argue Morgan, for sure. The hope is that Smith can be there some day, but she has a lot of scoring to do if she wants to be anywhere near those three, who are all certifiable legends.
JS: There's a difference between best and most important, and a lot of people struggle to differentiate the two. Morgan may be the most important USWNT player of all time. She was the face of the game for more than a decade, led the march for equal pay, became a serial winner and broke barriers. In the debate of who's the best, it doesn't matter. Alex is the most important, and that's what her legacy should be. A truly remarkable career.
AL: This might be a controversial opinion, but where’s the love for Wambach? She not only holds the record for the most goals scored by a USWNT player (184 compared to Alex Morgan’s 123) but was also recognized as the top player in the world with her FIFA World Player of the Year award in 2012. While women’s soccer has become more competitive in Morgan’s era, Wambach’s records still stand as a testament to her impact on the game.
It’s true that Wambach had some off-the-pitch controversies, whereas Morgan is known for her professionalism both on and off the field. But if we’re focusing purely on accomplishments, Wambach’s achievements are remarkable.
Regarding Smith, her talent is undeniable, but it’s uncertain whether she will have the same level of dominance as Wambach and Morgan. There are several young USWNT players, such as Jaedyn Shaw, who could also make strong cases for the striker position in the future.