Reyna participated in only 52 minutes at the 2022 FIFA World Cup. Analysts conjectured that there might have been problems inside the team because he was benched for the entirety of the group stage of the tournament.
USMNT head coach Gregg Berhalter confirmed that the team had held a meeting to decide whether or not that player would be allowed to stay with the team in Qatar for the remainder of the tournament. He also publicly addressed concerns regarding an anonymous player for a lack of commitment and a poor attitude.
On December 12, 2022, Reyna acknowledged that he was the player that Berhalter had been talking about. He also apologised for his actions and criticised Berhalter's choice to make the information public. It was discovered in January 2023 that Berhalter had been questioned throughout the competition over damaging personal information that had been communicated to superiors. Reyna's mother, Danielle Reyna, revealed that it was she who contacted the U.S. Soccer Federation about the violent incident involving Berhalter and his wife in 1991.