The West went up early in the first half, with St. Louis CITY SC attacker Lorenzo Cornelius setting up a dime of a pass to see a teammate slot home in a tight space.
The East then responded in first-half stoppage time through New England Revolution academy player Cristiano Oliveira to draw level. Then, to kick off the second half, Orlando City academy midfielder Gustavo Carballo came out of the break to give the East a 2-1 lead, bagging from distance with a blistering effort.
The West then responded through FC Dallas's Steel Cook to draw level at 2-2. That's where things really started to heat up.
Columbus Crew attacker Prince Forfor followed up to restore the East's lead to make it 3-2, before the West responded nearly immediately, with Vancouver Whitecaps academy forward Tyler Brown drawing level. Brown rounded the goalkeeper with ease on the counter and dribbled it into the net.
However, the East were once again on the attacking foot, and were awarded a penalty kick just five minutes later.
Up stepped Johnson, who finished clinically, to give the East a thrilling victory.