Earps has been named as one of three finalists for FIFA's The Best Goalkeeper Award. The stopper is in contention along with Spain and Barcelona's Catalina Coll as well as Australia's No. 1 Mackenzie Arnold. The winner will be announced at a ceremony in London on 15 January 2024. All three players starred at the Women's World Cup in the summer. Coll was part of the Spain squad that won the tournament, Earps took home the Golden Glove award and Arnold kept four clean sheets for the Matildas.