The Juventus winger's red card put the USMNT at a disadvantage instantly, handing the upper-hand to Panama. The U.S. overcame adversity almost instantly, with Folarin Balogun finding his second goal of Copa America to open the scoring in the match.
However, that disadvantage resurfaced quickly, with Panama equalizing just minutes later.
The U.S. adjusted for the one-man difference at halftime with a triple-substitution, and it nearly worked. Panama's perseverance paid off though, finding a winner with minutes to spare in regulation.