Despite being a combative midfielder playing at the highest level for a decade, Casemiro rarely got into trouble with referees until this year.
In nine seasons with Real Madrid and one with Porto, he was never shown a straight red card.
He was dismissed for double bookings for Madrid on two occasions, against Barcelona in 2021 and Real Valladolid in 2019, and once for Sao Paulo, in 2012.
In 69 matches for Brazil, meanwhile, he has never been sent off.
As Ten Hag put it after the Southampton game: "Casemiro played over 500 games in Europe and never once got a red card. Now he has two in the Premier League."
His previous record might have something to do with the special attention he shows to referees.
A report by The Telegraph last year said Casemiro gets a member of staff to compile a dossier on each referee he is due to come up against and that he took English lessons so he could communicate better with officials.
In Spain, Casemiro's ability to escape red cards despite flying into challenges and routinely halting opposition play with fouls became a running joke.
Indeed, it is telling that both of his straight red cards with United have been given following VAR reviews.
All the charm in the world and good manners cannot reach the officials in the VAR room.
Challenges are now forensically examined and pawed over in slow-motion, making them look worse than they appear at first glance.
But that is the state of the game in 2023 and Casemiro has little choice but to adapt.