Phil Parkinson’s side made the short trip to The Croud Meadow hoping to replicate their heroics from last season – when they saw off Championship side Coventry to book a fourth-round date with Premier League-bound Sheffield United. Local rivalry added extra spice to a contest in Shropshire, with the League One hosts determined not to buckle under pressure from fourth-tier opponents.
Wrexham loaded their ranks with attacking firepower, but the likes of Paul Mullin and Steven Fletcher barely had a sniff as the Shrews found a way of frustrating opponents that are usually full of goals. It was the home side that created the better opportunities, with Tunmise Sobowale somehow managing to fire over the top of a gaping net midway through the first half.
Mullin did have one poked effort from a tight angle beaten away early in the second 45, but it was Shrewsbury that looked the more likely to force a breakthrough – with Mal Benning hitting the top of the crossbar just past the hour mark. The only goal of the game arrived in the 72nd minute, with O’Connor bundling in from close range via a huge stroke of luck, with more glorious chances passed up by the hosts in the closing stages.