20230603 Ilikay Gundogan(C)Getty Images

Ilkay Gundogan is great - but Man City star is not the summer signing Barcelona need

When Erling Haaland went through an eerie dry spell towards the end of the season, and had the audacity to fail to score in a handful of games, Man City required another attacking option.

Their answer to their mystical striking force momentarily faltering was a silky central midfielder. Over a crucial four-game stretch, llkay Gundogan bagged four and added two assists, including a brace to see off Everton in what was regarded as a potential point of failure as they held off Arsenal in the Premier League title race.

His first against the Toffees was a finish Haaland would be envious of, a deft touch on his right thigh, with a half pivot and quick flick into the bottom corner — all without looking at the goal.

He was at it again in the FA Cup final, scoring both of City's goals against a dogged Manchester United side, playing a central role as his side lifted their second of three trophies in a historic season.

That run captured one element of Gundogan's game: the sneakily impactful goalscorer. But there are other versions, too. There is Gundogan the creator, Gundogan the composed distributor, and Gundogan the dribbler.

Pep Guardiola has fashioned a near-perfect attacking midfielder out of an injury-prone player whose career was slowly fading due to a series of fitness issues. But his time at the Etihad Stadium appears to be coming to an end, and Barcelona have all-but sealed his signature on a two-year contract.

Although they now have him, Gundogan is not the player the Blaugrana needed. At Man City, he's a cult hero and perennial Premier League champion. For Barcelona, he is an imperfect fit, and not the type of player the Blaugrana require to defend their La Liga crown.

Article continues below