interview
Article by
Krishan Davis
“Is that a joke?!” The reaction of Arsenal’s Mariona Caldentey speaks volumes as she discovers she will be asked questions about her fashion choices after scooping the Women’s Super League Players’ Player of the Year award (don’t worry, she was joking). When you’re not massively interested in how you dress, the Spain star - who wears a two-piece ensemble featuring a waistcoat with twisted buttons - says comfort and convenience are the most important things, with no need to go on a spending spree. “I'm wearing a suit with dark blue, because I feel comfy,” she says. “I had it ready at home, so it was easy.”
We all know that feeling of scrambling around for an outfit at the last minute ahead of an event that’s been in the calendar for months, racing around the shops and trawling the internet for inspiration. Championship Players’ Player of the Year, James Trafford, had a simple solution for that stress ahead of the ceremony in his hometown - reusing a suit he already owned and getting his girlfriend to do a bit of shopping for him at a very normal high street store. “Not going to lie, I got it [my suit] for the last awards, the club awards we had last season,” he says with a smile. The black suit is simple, and the Manchester City goalkeeper, recognised for his exploits with Burnley, has paired it with a black tie and black shoes. “My missus got me a tie from Next.” And the shoes? “I got them at the Trafford Centre,” he humbly reveals. It just goes to show that not every footballer wants to shell out half their paycheque on an ever-rotating wardrobe.
However, there are, of course, plenty of stars who do prefer the finer things in life. Take PFA Young Player of the Year winner Morgan Rogers, for example, who rocked up to the ceremony dripping in designer clobber - an approach plenty of the biggest names would take to such an event. He wears a double-breasted black suit, a crisp white shirt with no tie and an embellished collar and chunky, black, buckled shoes. “Dior head to toe. Nice, innit?” he says cheekily. “It fits well. Looks good…hopefully.” Asked about his favourite brands in general, the Aston Villa and England star doubles down: “I think there's too many. I'll say Dior just because I'm wearing it. I think that's the go-to.”
2025 Men’s PFA Players’ Player of the Year
2025 Women’s PFA Players’ Player of the Year
2025 Men’s Young Player of the Year
2025 Women’s Young Player of the Year
2025 Championship Players’ Player of the Year
If you feel slightly out of depth with that big event fast approaching or simply want someone else to take the decision-making process off your hands, a stylist is another smart way to go (if you have the spare cash knocking about). That’s what Women’s PFA Young Player of the Year, Olivia Smith, opted for - fresh from completing a world-record transfer from Liverpool to Arsenal. Wearing a classic, black cowl-neck gown and a necklace made up of a string of love hearts, she says: “The dress is Norma Kamali and then the jewellery is Swarovski. My stylist, Jojo, actually picked it out for me. I kind of gave her an idea of what I wanted to go for, just something classy, and I think she definitely delivered.”
If you want to play it safe, then going classic is always the best bet, and there are few safer pairs of hands than former England manager Sir Gareth Southgate, who was honoured for his contributions to football with a PFA Merit Award in Manchester, alongside ex-Chelsea boss Emma Hayes. Southgate became an accidental fashion icon during his time in charge of the Three Lions, and here he’s dressed in a textbook black suit consisting of a dinner jacket, black tie and tie clip, and black patent leather shoes. “I had that debate as to whether a tie or a bow tie,” he says. “I went with the tie, took a bit of advice from my son on that. So if I've messed that up...[laughs]. I always think patent [shoes] for a dinner jacket event. Everybody has a different feel on that, don't they?”
Mohamed Salah became the first player ever to win the PFA Players’ Player of the Year award three times as he scooped the men’s prize in Manchester after a stellar 2024-25 campaign. The Liverpool talisman previously won it in 2018 and 2022.
Another consideration for everyone who has more worldly experience than your average footballer is dressing age appropriately - something Southgate and Hayes were keen to achieve. “I'm conscious of not trying too hard to be down with the kids,” Southgate admits. “But also I think I'm still young enough and physically fit enough to wear fairly up-to-date stuff. But yeah, when you get to my age, you have got to find that right balance.” Asked how she would describe her personal style and choices on nights like this, USMNT boss Hayes - who wears a black Adriana Papell jumpsuit with big satin lapels - echoes that sentiment: “Just like Emma [laughs]. Classic, I would say. Classic style. Comfort, but classic. And middle-aged.”
We might put them on a pedestal as super-human players and tacticians when they are in the familiar surroundings of a football stadium, but it’s reassuring how human our heroes become when they are taken out of their comfort zone and are faced with the same mundane decisions as everyone else. From comfort-first to head-to-toe Dior, our PFA winners prove there’s no single formula for mastering the red carpet. Whether it’s a last-minute suit from the high street or a carefully curated designer look, it’s all about achieving that same individuality and self-expression that defines them as athletes and coaches.