All of the League Two PFA Players’ Player of the Year nominees bar Lowe were also named in the 2024-25 PFA League Two Team of the Year, with no one club dominating the XI. There are representatives from the likes of Wimbledon, Grimsby and Bradford, though there wasn't any space for runners-up Port Vale.
| POSITION | PLAYER (TEAM) |
| Goalkeeper | Owen Goodman (Wimbledon) |
| Defender | Mickey Demetriou (Crewe) |
| Defender | Taylor Allen (Walsall) |
| Defender | Denver Hume (Grimsby) |
| Defender | Brad Halliday (Bradford) |
| Midfielder | Luke Molyneux (Doncaster) |
| Midfielder | Jack Payne (Colchester) |
| Midfielder | George Abbott (Notts County) |
| Forward | Michael Cheek (Bromley) |
| Forward | David McGoldrick (Notts County) |
| Forward | Alassana Jatta (Notts County) |