From May 2016 to October 2023, Arsenal went a staggering 15 Premier League games without a win against City, losing 13 of those fixtures. Guardiola had the Gunners' number, and one way or another knew how to get the better of them.
Arteta gave up being Guardiola's assistant to take the top job at the Emirates Stadium in December 2019, and though league success against his mentor eluded him, he did strike a hammer blow in his first season, knocking his former side out of the FA Cup at the semi-final stage. Victory in the final against Chelsea ensured Arteta had enough credit in the bank to survive a rocky 2020-21 campaign and beginning to the following 2021-22 season, which included a 5-0 drubbing at the Etihad.
That defeat was the turning point in Arteta's reign. From there, he began weeding out the old guard and building around his young core of players, empowering the likes of Bukayo Saka, Martin Odegaard and Gabriel Martinelli. When City made the trip down to the Emirates a few months later, Arsenal swarmed and overwhelmed the champions with youth and endeavour. Alas, that still wasn't enough, as the visitors secured a late 2-1 victory following a string of questionable refereeing decisions.
Arsenal missed out on a Champions League spot by two points that season, but the following term they were equals with City, leading the standings for a record 250 days before collapsing down the stretch. Crucially, they lost twice to Guardiola's side and finished five points adrift of them.
The nail in the coffin came in the final week of April 2023, a 4-1 dismantling letting the world know who the best team in England truly were. This was another flashpoint in Arteta's timeline, completely changing his approach to future meetings with City. No longer would Arsenal try and out-football them, rather tighten the game up and narrow all margins.
This has largely worked. The Gunners prevailed 1-0 at the Emirates in October 2023 to end their barren streak against City, before holding them to a 0-0 draw later in the season. Yet once more, this wasn't enough to take home the title, even if this time the race went to the wire and was only decided by a single point.
The message from the outside world was clear when Arsenal made the journey north to Manchester towards the start of 2024-25 - if you want to pip City to top spot, you'll have to beat them in their back yard. Whereas the stalemate in March 2024 was incredibly dull and without event, the Gunners showed far more ambition this time around. Haaland's opener was quickly cancelled out by a worldie from Riccardo Calafiori, and a header from set-piece extraordinaire Gabriel Magalhaes saw them lead at the Etihad for the first time in nearly a decade.
Trossard's dismissal shortly before half-time changed the game entirely, and so Arsenal resorted to the shut-up-shop approach. It was a John Stones strike away from working, too. The devastation in the travelling camp branched between melancholy and fury, with Haaland's 'humble' line only serving to boil frustration. It may yet turn out to be one more bookmark in Arteta's tale.