Fans on social media were amazed to see 37-year-old Huddlestone rolling back the years for United's U21s, who are able to field up to five overage players in their lineup in accordance with current Premier League 2 rules.
"Tom Huddlestone in 2024??? This must be some alternate universe 😭😭😭," an X account named @UTDPsalm wrote.
Reacting immediately after Huddlestone's goal, @NathSalt1 said: "Tom Huddlestone has just made it 2-0 and I'm absolutely fascinated by the role he plays. Would be so easy for him to have bounced around lower league clubs to see out his career but his playing-coaching hybrid role is a model others could follow."
Meanwhile, an account named @Rzj77_ joked: "Starboy. Carrington has done it again with this Tom Huddlestone guy."
The outpouring of disbelief continued via @KippaxWill, who said: "37 year old Tom Huddlestone has scored for united's academy side tonight in the derby. THIRTY. SEVEN. ACADEMY."
Another fan account named @Realisiah1 added in a sarcastic tone: "Tom Huddlestone is a player I think has very good potential and could be in line for a senior call up. (Let’s see who all takes this serious)."