Ernest Wendo gave the host the lead in the 28th minute, but Stima responded immediately after the break to force a draw with the defending champions.
While the Kisumu-based side dropped two points eventually, a draw, against the defending champions, coming just a day after they were docked three points by the Kenyan Premier League for fielding an ineligible player against Tusker, demonstrated the grittiness of the newly promoted side when you talk about the title challenge.
Wendo linked up with Dennis Oliech and Jacques Tuyisenge for the opener, but Vincent Odongo restored parity for the visitors just five minutes after the restart.
Oliech blew away five clear chances and for sure the experienced striker will take a bigger portion of the blame for the result.
Though still unbeaten in five league games, a draw against a Stima side was not the best result Hassan Oktay had hoped for ahead of the Sunday’s Caf Confederation Cup match against Hussein Dey of Algeria.
Oktay also suffered a major blow ahead of Sunday’s game after defender Joash Onyango had to be pulled out of the game with an injury, just five minutes to the break.
The draw left Gor Mahia second on 27th points, one ahead of leaders Bandari while Stima moved to sixth on 17 points.
Gor Mahia XI : Fredrick Odhiambo (GK), Philemon Otieno, Geoffrey Ochieng, Joash Onyango, Charles Momanyi, Ernest Wendo, George Odhiambo, Lawrence Juma, Denis Oliech, Jacques Tuyisenge, Samuel Onyango
Subs: Shaban Odhoji (GK), Joakim Oluoch, Bernard Ondiek, Francis Kahata.
Western Stima XI : Samuel Odhiambo (GK), Kevin Akongo, Samuel Olare, Luke Ochieng, Maurice Ojwang, David Ojwang, Kote Berry, James Ogada, Fredrick Nyarombo, Vincent Likare, Henry Onyango.
Subs: Stephen Otieno (GK), Martin Oduor, Victor Oduor, Herbert Kopany, Junior Mukisa, Kennedy Otieno.