This page contains affiliate links. When you purchase through the links provided, we may earn a commission.
Xherdan Shaqiri Chicago Fire 2023Getty Images

Xherdan Shaqiri has finally turned up! MLS winners and losers as ex-Liverpool star shows his class for Chicago Fire

Ahh, MLS Rivalry Week. It's a time for big games to be decided in big moments by big stars, although it isn't always the stars that shine brightest during these matches. From international superstars to overlooked MLS veterans, the first half of MLS Rivalry Week was certainly typical: fierce, chaotic, frenzied and, most of all, a bit weird.

A total of nine red cards were handed out over the weekend, adding an additional layer of messiness to a week that always promises chaos. And chaos is what we got. There were collisions on the field and off of it, with mayhem north of the border leading the way.

Some struggling clubs, like the Chicago Fire, New York Red Bulls and Sporting KC, put together what could be season-defining performances against a rival, while others, like Atlanta United and Toronto FC, fell flat on their face in big moments.

Big goals, non-celebrations, "criminal" defending and a thrown megaphone... Rivalry Week never fails to disappoint!

This page contains affiliate links. When you subscribe through the links provided, we may earn a commission.

Sign up here for MLS Season Pass through Apple TV and watch every MLS match, including the playoffs!

  • Shaqiri Chicago FireGetty

    WINNER: Xherdan Shaqiri

    The critics have been coming for Shaqiri, and rightfully so. The former Liverpool attacker has been, at his best, okay and, at his worst, downright bad in 2023. In this league, you can't afford for a player on Shaqiri's salary to be playing at that level, and the Fire's record indicates that.

    Head coach Ezra Hendrickson paid for it with his job, as the Fire begin a new-ish era under a returning Frank Klopas. Klopas' first game, though, saw a different Shaqiri, one that very much looked like the player everyone should expect him to be.

    Shaqiri notched an assist in the 1-0 win over St. Louis City SC, teeing up Rafael Czichos for the game's only goal. It was the Swiss star's first goal contribution of the season after 18 (seven goals and 11 assists) in 2022. It wasn't just the assist, that stood out though, as Shaqiri, who was played as more of a No.10, finally made a massive impact on a game.

    “Today [Shaqiri] played like a DP, like he should play every game,” Klopas said. The No.10 role may be the way forward for Shaqiri, who has been largely outplayed by 19-year-old starlet Brian Gutierrez. Those two connecting will likely be the difference between success and failure this season for a Fire team that still has a lot of work to do.

  • Advertisement
  • Federico Bernardeschi Toronto 2022-23Getty Images

    LOSER: Toronto FC

    For all of the club's spending and ambition, Toronto FC find themselves in last place in the Eastern Conference. And, after two losses to the rival CF Montreal in less than a week, you have to start wondering if this is rock bottom.

    TFC fell to Montreal in both the Canadian Cup and in MLS, capping another disastrous week in what has been a disastrous season. Despite possessing stars like Federico Bernardeschi and Lorenzo Insigne, as well as a legendary MLS coach in Bob Bradley, TFC have been a total mess, with this week serving as the worst moment so far.

    It was a week of frustration, with tempers flaring on and off the field. After the Canadian Cup defeat, Mark-Anthony Kaye got into it with a TFC supporter, while both sets of players came together during CF Montreal's league win.

    “It was just a bad blip in the history of Toronto FC, and I hope that that never happens again," Kaye said of his back-and-forth with a fan, who ultimately threw his megaphone towards the Canadian star. "And from a player standpoint, I just want to say that we respect the fans wholeheartedly and we just expect the same respect back, so that we can work together to bring this club back to where it belongs."

    Doing that will be difficult, based on what we've seen. With just two wins from 12 matches and plenty of key contributors out injured, it may be a while before TFC figure it out.

  • New York Red Bulls 2023Getty

    WINNER: Troy Lesesne & the New York Red Bulls

    If you value first impressions, you'd have to say that Lesense is off to a good start. In his first MLS match since replacing the fired Gerhard Struber, Lesense led the Red Bulls to a 1-0 win over rivals New York City FC. It was his second win since taking over, with the Red Bulls having topped D.C. United 1-0 in the U.S. Open Cup earlier in the week.

    "It's been a lot," Lesesne said after the win. "It's been a lot this week, and it will be a lot going forward. But that's what you hope for. Whenever you get an opportunity like this, you want to obviously make the most of it.

    "I'm at a great club and I've been given an opportunity that I want to try and maximize. And you know, when you play in a derby like this, you get a real sense of what it means to this club even more."

    Saturday's win was far from pretty, with Omir Fernandez's 76th-minute strike being all that separated the two teams. Given the Red Bulls' situation, though, they won't worry about pretty. Right now, they really just need results.

    Even with the win, the Red Bulls are in 14th place, with just 12 points through as many matches. Still, there aren't many better things to build on than a derby win, are there?

    "It's beautiful, especially when I'm hearing those [NYCFC] fans shut up in the corner," homegrown star John Tolkin said on MLS 360 postgame. "I was hearing them all second half. So back in the stadium, any time you can get a derby win, it's like the best feeling in the world."

  • Adrian Heath MinnesotaGetty

    LOSER: Minnesota United

    Essentially, a defensive disaster. Facing a Sporting KC team that has been reeling all season, the Loons were pummeled 3-0 at Children's Mercy Park. It was a loss that left Adrian Heath fuming, as his side let a team that has been one of the league's worst run rampant.

    Heath described the defending as "poor" and "criminal" postgame, and he isn't wrong. Add in a missed penalty from Sang Bin Jeong to make matters worse, too. With the loss, Minnesota have just one point from their last six games. This is a rough patch, to say the least.

    On the other side of that, though, is Sporting KC, who have now won two straight after failing to win in their first 10. “Make no mistake about it, there's a side of me that is vengeful, for sure,” head coach Peter Vermes said after the match. “I want to show everybody that we are that good. And I know inside the locker room, inside the group that we want to show everybody that we are that good.”

    Sporting KC still have a lot of work to do, and it remains to be seen if they can dig themselves out of their own hole. But on the flipside, this was a game Minnesota could not and should not have lost, as they now find themselves facing questions due to their own rough patch.

  • Meram Charlotte Atlanta 2023Getty

    WINNER: Justin Meram

    Meram chose not to celebrate, but the rest of Charlotte FC sure as hell did. This was a massive win for them, a massive win for their season. They went down to Atlanta and beat the snot out of their big rival, with the former Five Stripes winger Meram doing the bulk of the damage.

    Meram, the MLS veteran recently acquired from Real Salt Lake, scored two of the three goals in the 3-1 win. It's the second consecutive week Atlanta were undone by a former player, with Josef Martinez having scored twice against them in a loss to Inter Miami.

    Already down 1-0 due to a 18th-minute Meram goal, Atlanta were effectively doomed by Andrew Gutman's 51st-minute red card. Karol Swiderski scored the ensuing penalty before Meram scored again five minutes later and the game was done and dusted.

    It was a fantastic performance from Meram, who refused to celebrate against his former club, where he won his only two career trophies during the 2019 season. “I was going through a rough time in my career and when I came to Atlanta., they revived me, and they brought me so much confidence,” he said. “The fans supported me, and helped uplift me through a difficult time.

    “I was traded a few times in a short span when I came here. The group within the organization, they really helped me, and I took my chance, and I flourished here, and we won a couple of trophies and I’m just forever I'm grateful for this club. Part of me feels that if I never made my move here, I don't know if I'd still be playing.”

    Charlotte have now won three of their last four, with this latest win coming without DP striker Enzo Copetti, who was suspended due to yellow card accumulation. Atlanta, meanwhile, have lost four straight in all competitions.