Godoy's effort put Nashville up 2-1 right before the halftime break, with the 34-year-old scoring their second goal of first half stoppage-time. However, a late Crew goal in the 79th minute drew them level, with the two sides playing out the remainder of the match at a stalemate.
The Crew could have taken three points on the night, but a missed penalty kick in the 49th minute by Diego Rossi set them back farther than they would have hoped.