Milner has not missed a spot-kick since November 2009, having converted 10 consecutive penalties prior to Forster’s stop.
England international Forster made eight saves on the day and became the first goalkeeper to save a penalty at Anfield since May 2015.
But did you know he could take them, too?
Fraser Forster's penalty challenge
He can take them too! Southampton FC's Fraser Forster takes the Penalty Challenge #NeverMoreSurePosted by Goal.com on Saturday, May 13, 2017
Sure put him to the test against Studs Up Presenter Rory Jennings, asking Forster not only to stop out of his comfort zone and experience the pressure that comes with taking a penalty, but to tell us where he was going to put them, too.
Poor Rory had no chance – at least he didn’t concede all four of them!