+18 | Commercial Content | T&C's Apply | Play Responsibly | Publishing Principles
Man Utd mediocrity GFX Getty

Man Utd play like they're battling relegation under Erik ten Hag - and FA Cup exit would prove his 'right direction' claim is completely ludicrous

Erik ten Hag fooled everyone into thinking Manchester United had turned a corner after a strong start to 2024, with four successive Premier League wins taking them back to within sight of the top four. Results started to turn after he welcomed key players back from injury, just as he predicted would happen, and talk of his potential dismissal died down.

But all the problems that were masked by individual moments during that mini-resurgence came rushing back to the surface when Fulham arrived at Old Trafford on Saturday. The Cottagers emerged with a 2-1 victory, their first at the Theatre of Dreams in 21 years, thanks to a 97th-minute strike from Alex Iwobi.

It was only the second time Marco Silva's side have won away all season, but they fully deserved the three points after slicing through United's midfield at will. It was the hosts' 10th Premier League loss of the season, one more than they recorded throughout the entire 2022-23 campaign, and it leaves them eight points behind Aston Villa in the race for the final Champions League spot.

Nottingham Forest are up next in the fifth round of the FA Cup, and they will fancy their chances of repeating their 2-1 win over United - achieved at the City Ground in December - mainly because Ten Hag is still refusing to budge on a set of principles that makes his team far too easy to play against.

  • Casemiro-Man-UtdGetty

    'You have to see the bigger picture'

    "After one defeat you have to see the bigger picture, and the bigger picture looks very good," Ten Hag said at his latest post-match press conference. "We have to catch up in certain positions and get the injuries back, then we will be more in balance and also strengthen the squad in the transfer windows. You see there are many good players coming up and real high-potential players. They will be getting better, so definitely we are going in the right direction."

    The United boss appeared to be referencing Sir Jim Ratcliffe's purchase of a 25 percent stake in the club, with the INEOS chairman currently in the process of putting a new recruitment team in place to overhaul the muddled transfer policy that has been so damaging to the club over the past decade.

    But at this rate, there is a very good chance Ten Hag won't be involved in the revolution. Yes, United badly missed Rasmus Hojlund against Fulham, as the Danish striker had been on a scintillating six-match scoring run, and losing Casemiro to a head injury early in the second half was a cruel blow.

    United are also having to make do without star defensive duo Luke Shaw and Lisandro Martinez, but regardless of what starting XI Ten Hag puts out, the theme is always the same. The 54-year-old insists on a high press that his players are incapable of committing to, either through a lack of quality or drive, and opposing teams exploit the massive gaps they leave in the middle of the pitch.

  • Advertisement
  • Maguire-Iwobi-Man-UtdGetty

    Execution struggles

    Across their last five games against Fulham, Luton, Aston Villa, West Ham and Wolves, United have allowed 100 shots at their goal. Ten Hag wants his team to dictate the pace of matches and play quick, incisive passes once they move into the final third, but the players lack the technical quality to execute his vision.

    Fulham were just the latest team to play through United's press and pounce on their sloppy passing time and time again. The Red Devils always look vulnerable in and out of possession, and a lack of mobility in defence often leaves Andre Onana exposed between the sticks.

    That was clear for all to see for Iwobi's winner, which came after a trademark run from Adama Traore. The former Barcelona winger initially picked the ball up in his own half before bursting past Christian Eriksen and Harry Maguire, and was allowed to advance all the way to the edge of the box before laying it off for Iwobi, who then fooled Amad Diallo and Diogo Dalot with a simple touch onto his right foot before lashing into the bottom corner.

    In truth, Ten Hag's men didn't really show any signs of life in the game at all until Maguire headed in an 89th-minute equaliser, as Fulham boss Silva alluded to after the final whistle. "It is clear in my opinion the better team on the pitch won the game," he said. "We are the team that created the most chances, that played better and tried to win most of the moments of the game."

    United are playing like a side battling to avoid relegation, not one chasing a seat at Europe's top table, and most of the blame has to fall on Ten Hag.

  • 20240224 Erik ten Hag(C)Getty Images

    Ten Hag definitely not 'best in class'

    “We need to populate all the key roles with people who are best in class, 10 out of 10s,” Sir Jim Ratcliffe said when sitting down for a media briefing after seeing his minority takeover at Old Trafford approved last week.

    Omar Berrada has already been appointed as United's new CEO after being lured away from Manchester City, and INEOS are now working to bring in Newcastle sporting director Dan Ashworth. Top marks must be given for those ambitious moves, but none of the work behind the scenes will pay off if United don't have the right man sitting in the dugout.

    After 21 months in charge, it's pretty clear that's not Ten Hag. He's spent £410 million ($500m) on 16 new players since moving to Old Trafford from Ajax, but it could be argued that none of them have been a success.

    Casemiro and Lisandro Martinez had impressive debut seasons as United secured a third-place Premier League finish and the Carabao Cup, but the former's age has caught up with him this term and the latter has been ravaged by injury. Brazilian forward Antony, meanwhile, has done absolutely nothing to justify his £85m ($108m) price tag and now finds himself behind Alejandro Garnacho and Amad Diallo in the squad pecking order.

    Signings from last summer such as Onana and Mason Mount have also proven to be huge missteps, and even Hojlund took months to settle after his move from Atalanta, after United opted to go for the youngster instead of Premier League goal king Harry Kane. It's little wonder, then, that the Red Devils are failing to put Ten Hag's philosophy into practice.

    Ratcliffe's right-hand man Sir David Brailsford was present to watch United's latest abject display, and wouldn't have had anything positive to report back. There is nothing to suggest that Ten Hag is a "10 out of 10" manager right now, and the club won't properly start to move forward until he's gone.

  • Haaland-Man-UtdGetty

    Man City could strike final blow

    United's 2023-24 campaign has been a complete disaster, and nothing can change that now. There may not even be anything left to play for by the start of next week.

    Ten Hag will be on the brink again if he can't guide United to the FA Cup quarter-finals at Forest's expense in midweek, which would prove once and for all his "right direction" claim is completely ludicrous. He will take his band of misfits to the Etihad Stadium four days later for a huge derby encounter against City, with 15 points currently separating the two Manchester rivals - but the gulf in class between them is far bigger than that.

    United were battered 3-0 by their noisy neighbours at Old Trafford in the reverse fixture, and the final scoreline could have been far worse. City had 21 shots at goal to the home side's seven and dominated possession throughout, with Erling Haaland netting a brace before Phil Foden rounded off a comfortable victory.

    Another humiliation would effectively end United's Champions League qualification hopes, and surely leave Ratcliffe with no choice but tear up Ten Hag's contract one year early.

  • Erik ten Hag Manchester United 2023-24Getty Images

    Damning evidence mounting

    Any United fans retaining faith in Ten Hag are kidding themselves at this point, and the statistics back up that argument. The Red Devils are on zero goal difference after 26 Premier League games, and they've broken a host of unwanted records this season.

    Ten Hag has overseen eight home defeats in all competitions, and one more will see United equal their worst ever season at Old Trafford, dating back to 1973-74. The Red Devils lost four of their opening seven league games for the first time ever, and they conceded 15 goals on their way to crashing out of the Champions League group stage - more than any other Premier League team in history.

    United have now faced a grand total of 417 shots in the English top-flight this season, too, with only Sheffield United, Luton and West Ham more open at the back. Ten Hag can urge people to focus on the "bigger picture" all he wants, but he's sounding more desperate with each inevitable setback, and the evidence against him his mounting.

  • Man Utd Brailsford GFXGetty

    No point wasting any more time

    No one fears coming up against United anymore. There have been so many devastating lows in the post-Sir Alex Ferguson era, but the standard of football being played on Ten Hag's watch is worse than any of his predecessors.

    Not only has the former Ajax coach populated the squad with mediocre players, but he is also failing to get the best out of pre-existing stars. Marcus Rashford and Bruno Fernandes stand out most in that regard: two players with bags of talent who have been reduced to figures of ridicule.

    They no longer make the decisive impact in games, while some of the most experienced members of the squad like Christian Eriksen and Raphael Varane have shrunk under the weight of responsibility. The only bright spots have come from Hojlund, Garnacho and academy graduate Kobbie Mainoo, who have displayed a fearlessness that was a staple of Ferguson's best teams.

    If United's last route to silverware is closed off at Forest on Wednesday night, a proper inquest will have to begin. Ratcliffe has vowed to knock City and Liverpool "off their perch" within the next three years, which won't be possible unless serious improvement on the pitch is made immediately.

    It's already abundantly clear that Ten Hag is not equipped to deliver that. United must stop wasting time and put someone in place who is.