Player Ratings: Mohun Bagan 1-2 Mumbai FC

Mumbai FC ripped apart Mohun Bagan in the I-League clash between the two sides on Saturday, winning the match 2-1.’s Rahul Bali now rates the players’ performance in the match…..

Mohun Bagan  

Shilton Paul – 4.0  

The goalkeeper never looked at ease and it seems that the absence of Sangram Mukherjee would hurt Bagan.

N.S.Manju – 3  

Like most of his fellow Mohun Bagan defenders, he wasn't great either.

Deepak Mandal – 4  

The Indian international didn't have the best of games and was largely disappointing.  

Peter Odafe – 3  

Failed to hold the defensive line and was appalling at the back for Mohun Bagan against Mumbai FC  

Rino Antao – 4  

He allowed Mumbai FC's Aseem to freely run away with the ball. He was substituted at half time.

Shylo Malswamtulunga– 5  

Did marginally better than his most of his fellow Mohun Bagan midfielders but was still disappointing  

James Singh – 6  

Was the only Mohun Bagan midfielder who played well against Mumbai FC  

Rakesh Masih – 5  

Didn’t at all look like he was in any way up for this match; like most of the Mohun Bagan players he failed to do anything concrete    

Ishfaq Ahmed – 6.5

Was one of the chosen few Bagan players who did anything creative in the match; he created two or three good chances. 

Bhaichung Bhutia – 6  

He had a couple of decent chances but missed out on them. He was unlucky not to have scored late in the match when his shot hit the inside of the post.

Jose Barretto – 6.5  

The only Mohun Bagan player who was consistently a threat to Mumbai FC but unfortunately he didn’t get the support of his teammates.


Mohan Raj – 7

He did well after coming on and created a couple of good chances. Mohun Bagan should have started with the left back.

Lalwampuia – 6.5  

Came on as a substitute and looked lively. did look lively and also scored a goal that did sprout some hope for Mohun Bagan.

Lal Kamal Bhowmick - 4.5

His form has been dwindling and couldn't offer to the Green and Maroon. 

Mumbai FC  

Kalyan Chaubey- 7  

Was huge between the sticks for Mumbai FC and made one or two brilliant saves. 

Sanjay Parte – 6  

The skipper led from the front at the back.

James Dissiramah - 5  

Mumbai FC played as a unit and individual mistakes were covered up. Looked fairly ok.

Selwyn Fernandes - 6  

Did alright, defended well and kept the Mohun Bagan attackers at bay.   

Anas Edathodika - 6.5  

Played very well and seemed not to be too bothered by the big names in the Mohun Bagan line-up  

Aseem 6.5  

Was a constant threat when going forward. Mohun Bagan did little to stop him.

Riston Rodriguez - 6.5  

Was creative in the midfield for Mumbai FC and did not let the Mohun Bagan players take control of the area  

Subhash Chakraborty – 7  

Was one of the best midfielders in the match; he played on the right wing and was creative and imaginative throughout the match  

Kuluthungan - 7.5  

Played extremely well and scored a goal too for Mumbai FC  

Felix Aboagye - 8  

Another extremely well performing Mumbai FC player who exhibited superb football and smuggled terror into the hearts of the Mohun Bagan defenders.

Abel Hammond – 8  

Besides scoring for Mumbai FC, Hammond was a persistent nuisance for the Mohun Bgaan defenders and always looked like he could score again    


Abhishek Yadav – N/A  

Anish – N/A  

Kuttimani – N/A