Do you agree? You got a chance to have a second look at both goals below, and then decide yourself.
Shouldn't the Oscar go to Oscarine Masuluke? Or, was that delightful chip and vision from Siphiwe Tshabalala better?
They're both amazing goals, but you have to also admit that Masuluke's goal is going to be difficult for any goalkeeper to beat.
Should we say it's better just because he's a keeper? Should Shabba be disadvantaged for not being a keeper? That's maybe why Shabba won.
In the meantime, enjoy the banter between the fans right here.
This wonderful strike by Siphiwe Tshabalala is nominated for goal of the season at the #PSLAwards. See if it wins - LIVE on SS4 at 21:00. pic.twitter.com/ilawTn5g2H — SuperSport (@SuperSportTV) July 10, 2017